1. David Cook: Paul Rodgers was cheering, Simon was insane
2. David Hernandez: Not David Ruffin, Eddie Kendricks, etc., but who is? Just to be able to cut down a 6 minute great song to 2 minutes rates him high. Very good vocal
3. Jason Castro: Cheeseball song, but I thought he was better than the Stooges said he was. A little like Marty Casey doing Britney Spears on "Rockstar"
4. Chikieze: Comeback player of the year
5. Long Johns: Slow, tortured, but handicapped by a lack of a Stevie Nicks
6. Luke Menard: Someone tell Simon: "Freddie Mercury". Nice try, but Luke doesn't have the chops. His Patrick Dempsey-like looks will get him to next week
7. Vinny Barfuleta: I'm sorry, but it was the John Davidson version of "Imagine." I HATE his schmaltzy style, he ruined the song, and he's like a 17 year-old male Melinda Doolittle. And when will he admit that he won $100,000 on Star Search?
8. Danny Boy: Meh, and when he started singing it, I laughed
9. Robbie Carrico: You CANNOT baritone Lou Gramm; only slightly better than the guys on Season 2 of "Beauty And The Geek"
10. Jason Yeager: Viva Las Vegas! Slot machine lounge. Buh-Bye
B: Jason Yeager, Luke Menard
H: Long Johns, Vinny Barfuleta
G: Jason Yeager, Robbie Carrico
2. David Hernandez: Not David Ruffin, Eddie Kendricks, etc., but who is? Just to be able to cut down a 6 minute great song to 2 minutes rates him high. Very good vocal
3. Jason Castro: Cheeseball song, but I thought he was better than the Stooges said he was. A little like Marty Casey doing Britney Spears on "Rockstar"
4. Chikieze: Comeback player of the year
5. Long Johns: Slow, tortured, but handicapped by a lack of a Stevie Nicks
6. Luke Menard: Someone tell Simon: "Freddie Mercury". Nice try, but Luke doesn't have the chops. His Patrick Dempsey-like looks will get him to next week
7. Vinny Barfuleta: I'm sorry, but it was the John Davidson version of "Imagine." I HATE his schmaltzy style, he ruined the song, and he's like a 17 year-old male Melinda Doolittle. And when will he admit that he won $100,000 on Star Search?
8. Danny Boy: Meh, and when he started singing it, I laughed
9. Robbie Carrico: You CANNOT baritone Lou Gramm; only slightly better than the guys on Season 2 of "Beauty And The Geek"
10. Jason Yeager: Viva Las Vegas! Slot machine lounge. Buh-Bye
B: Jason Yeager, Luke Menard
H: Long Johns, Vinny Barfuleta
G: Jason Yeager, Robbie Carrico
