It's hard to judge without their intro videos yet, but I'll do my best. And I'd prefer a new thread since I don't like navigating through big threads, but it's your choice.

Alexis - 5, very unopinionated so far, just seems like UTR fodder
Amanda - 3, didn't like her the first time, but her copious amounts of cleavage bumps her up two points
Ami - 7, didn't see Vanuatu, but I dig hot lesbians
Chet - 4, if he's a reincarnation of Hatch, I'd be grateful, but he seems a bit too flaming
Cirie - 6, I wasn't crazy for her in EI, but she'll be fun to watch
Eliza - 6, didn't see Vanuatu, but she came on Sucks, so that's some credit
Erik - 8, fucking crazy hair + crappy job + loves Survivor = good
James - 6, never was my favourite guy, but he deserves a chance
Jason - 6, I can't find any faults, but nothing too good either
Joel - 7, he's obviously a beast, a firefighter, and probably the leader
Johnny Fairplay - 9, I love JFP, and he deserves a high stat before leaving
Jonathan - 9, up there with JFP
Kathy - 4, UTR/bitchy fodder
Mary - 2, UTR fodder
Michael - 8, how can we not give Mikey B a chance?
Natalie - 6, hot = chance
Ozzy - 4, MUTINEERS ARE THE FIRST TO DIE
Parvati - 4, boring the first time around AND a slut?
Tracy - 5, no preference
Yau Man - 6, little preference