we are using Edgic rules to attempt a prediction of the winner.Nope, we are using edgic guidelines. Were we to apply immutable rules, each one of us would, or should, independently, arrive at the same conclusions, time after time.
The fact that we never do suggests that each of us brings to the table their own interpretative arsenal. If you disagree with what is said, point out where you think there are inconsistencies or errors in the arguments. But don't don't do it on the basis of zealously defending what you think are unimpeachable rules that are cast in stone. Because they're not.
