| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 beatles20147 |
|||
|
Posts: 12556 (10/20/09 7:07 PM) Registered User |
WylDawg wrote:We'll mock them incessantly, natch. Seriously, that would be half the selling point. People would want to find out which poor saps would get out early once again--and hopefully by the time we've filled up on schadenfreude we'll be hooked enough to want to see the rest of it play out. |
||
 Katy Carney |
|||
|
Posts: 9035 (10/20/09 9:45 PM) |
I don't understand why anyone would be opposed to the idea. I think it's a neat hook and from a marketing perspective it isn't worse than
"biggest season ever" or whatever the hell Samoa's tag line was. Even the most casual of fans has someone from some season that they were bummed
to see go early, even if they will only remember them as "hey it's that one guy!"
Plus who would have thought we could ever hear the glorious words: "the winner of Survivor....Palomo Soto-Castillo!!!111" |
||
|
novaya |
|||
|
Posts: 1020 (10/21/09 3:25 AM) |
WylDawg wrote: 
Again, you ignore the elephant in the room, Wyl. Arguing "NO ONE REMEMBERS THESE PEOPLE!" is not a convincing counter-argument. Worse comes to worse, no -- the "average viewer" doesn't. But that doesn't mean that Amy from Guat (<33333333333333333334, ps) won't have an EPIC JOURNEY on her way to F3 domination, and that she won't captivate the hearts and minds of a general audience. The point is: you cannot argue that a season full of randoms like Samoa/any other season with new castaways can be AMAZING, yet a marketing hook like a "second chance" Survivor cannot. You can't argue on the one hand say "No one wants to watch these LOSERS the world clearly remembers as being LOSERS!" and then argue on the other that the general audience has committed their "loser" journeys to eternal brainspace memory status. DOES NOT FOLLOW. |
||
|
Kubin |
|||
|
Posts: 53 (10/21/09 7:23 AM) |
Not being memorable enough makes 2nd chance better than allstars because it will be more unpredictable and unlike allstars were you are expecting too much, @nd
chance can surprize viewers with all the drama those premerge people can make.
|
||
|
survivor300 |
|||
|
Posts: 3581 (10/21/09 7:42 AM) Registered User |
Fuck the 2nd chance... get some new fucking people already!!!! like me!
|
||
|
Kubin |
|||
|
Posts: 55 (10/21/09 9:32 PM) |
survivor300 wrote:One you get voted out early you'll be begging for 2nd chance. seriously.... |
||
|
survivor300 |
|||
|
Posts: 3586 (10/22/09 10:07 AM) Registered User |
^^ good point.LOL.. but I would make the jury, at least!
|
||
|
tutorial |
|||
|
Posts: 3845 (10/22/09 1:24 PM) Registered user |
Kubin wrote:Haha. That's quite true. I think a 2nd chance season would be a refreshing idea rather than to see Amanda and James play so many times, having the same game plan. 
|
||
|
Maximus20 |
|||
|
Posts: 174 (10/22/09 2:16 PM) |
I think its an awsome idea...for a future season.
I cant see them doing 2 "special" seasons in a row. I doubt they do Heroes VS Villians, and then "Second chance" right in a row. Maybe do 2nd chance in season 22. Because aren't they filming back to back now???? (I.E 21 and 22 will be filmed in the same spot) So odds are we're gonna get more specialty seasons in order to make up for the repeat locations. |
||
|
craig |
|||
|
Posts: 16343 (10/22/09 10:14 PM) Registered User |
Fuck the 2nd chance... get some new fucking people already!!!!2nd chancers who want to play again could end up as fresh characters playing a new and better game. But most rookie players, especially is recruits, make the same set of rookie mistakes. |
||
|
Survivorjus |
Second Chance | ||
|
Posts: 209 (10/23/09 2:57 PM) Registered User |
One Pre jury boots that MOST deserve a 2nd chance (for game play, eye candy, interesting story or just cus I like them :) )
Borneo - Gretchen Outback - Jeff Varner Africa - Silas (Kelly if Jury was allowed) Marquesas - Hunter Thailand - Tanya Amazon - Jeanne (Deena if Jury was alloweD) Pearl Islands - Michelle Vanuatu - Brady Palau - Johnathan Guatemala - Amy (close call with Brian C) Panama - Tina Cook Islands - JP Fiji - Liliana China - Aaron Micronesia - Tracy Gabon - Ace Tocantins - Spencer Samoa - Betsy 9 guys, 9 gals. Sounds good to me :) |
||
|
Survivorjus |
|||
|
Posts: 210 (10/23/09 2:59 PM) Registered User |
For the record, I think above would be an AMAZING season.
|
||
|
Kubin |
|||
|
Posts: 74 (10/23/09 3:08 PM) |
Put the biggest trainwreck premerge boots in one season will be better than any allstar season.
|
||
|
losemygrip |
|||
|
Posts: 153 (10/25/09 1:20 AM) Registered User |
Kubin wrote:LOL! No kidding! |
||
|
Kubin |
|||
|
Posts: 136 (10/29/09 10:02 PM) |
Liz is number one on my list. Bring back Liz!!!
|
||
|
qwerty |
|||
|
Posts: 35 (10/30/09 8:57 AM) |
My Cast -
Female - Samoa - Liz/Marisa, Betsy Tocantis - Caroline Gabon - Michelle, Jacquie China - Sherea Palau - Wanda Outback - Kimmi Male - Gabon - Ace China - Aaron CI - J.P Tocantis - Spencer Palau - Jonathan Micronesia - Joel/ Dave from China Marquesas - Hunter P.I. - Osten 16 Castaway, however, 4 castaway will join, 2 castaway are the people that keep applying for survivor and never got in. 1 man, 1 female. The other 2 castaway will be first juror. The Castaway gets to pick their own tribe, with the new tribal chief twist, in samoa. The cast will vote for who they want to be the leader, VOTES WILL NOT BE REVEALED, and the 4 highest is the tribe chief. Immediately, the tribe chief will pick a member and that member will pick another member, alternatively. 4 tribes 2 Tribes @ 16 castaway Tribe swap @ 14 castaway Double T.C. here 2 Tribe, 1 Beach @ 13 castaway (winning tribe gets to choose) Outcast twist @ 12 castaway (Both tribe goes to TC and vote out one member each, 2 members of the outcast will be voted in, just like in Pearls Island) Also, the losing tribe, will change beach and have to start afresh, losing all the camp eq.) Mutiny@ 11 (If no one switch, tribe leaders choose 1 to switch) Jury/Merge @ 9 (7 Jurors) Auction @ 8 Family Visit @ 6 Revenge of the Jury Challenge (If the jury wins, no immunity necklace) @ 5 Final @ 2 Kidnapping Twist, 2 idol at each tribe, ends at 1 challenge before merge. Exile island will be present @ the merge, 1 idol, but 2 castaway each time, from different tribe 3 idols of fun! I try to make the cast as "evil" as possible.. but the people that are out before merge seems so nice. That is why, there must be some twist like the mutiny, 2 people to exile. I hope some immunity challenges will be a remake of the old. |
||
|
TheBoyy |
|||
|
Posts: 25 (10/30/09 5:20 PM) Registered User |
qwerty wrote: Thank gawd you are not in charge of anything related to Survivor...worst post ever relating to Second Chance Survivor. |
||
|
Lexxan |
|||
|
Posts: 13 (10/31/09 1:00 PM) |
I love it if it would have this cast.
Tribe one: (Blue Buffs) [COLOUR SAMPLE] 1) Brook (Vanuatu) 2) Betsy (Samoa) 3) Mike (Australian Outback) 4) Flicka (Cook Islands) 5) Aaron (China) 6) Paloma (Gabon)* [Gina (Marquesas)] 7) Brian (Guatemala) 8) Michelle (Gabon)* [Liz (Samoa)] 9) Tracy (FvF) 10) Gabe (Marquesas) Tribe two: (Yellow Buffs) [COLOUR SAMPLE] 11) Tina (Exile Island) 12) Ace (Gabon) 13) Misty (Exile Island)* [Marisa (Samoa)] 14) Hunter (Marquesas) 15) Amy Guatemala 16) Brady (Vanuatu)* [Robb (Thailand)] 17) Angie (Palau) 18) Jonathan (Palau) 19) Nicole (Pearl Islands)* [ Jolanda (Palau)] 20) Cao Boi (Cook Islands) Minor details: -20 Contestants, two tribes (Buffs are [Sky] Blue and [Light] Yellow) -Jury starts at 11, Nine Jurors, Final 2 -Merge @ 9, (or 11 in case we have another Ulong/Ravu/FoaFoa/Fang, though I think that the tribes are matched quite evenly). Buff Colour is either Brown (Koror)or [Pine] Green (Mogo Mogo) -Fallen Comrades is the F3 Immunity Challenge. -No Exile Island, 1 HII (Hidden at the Merged Camp, Guatemala style) that's how I personally like it the most. ;) Otherwise, I pretty much do not care what happens, as long as it is fun to watch. :) * The Contestants with the Asterisks ("*") can be replaced by other Survivors (Suggestions between brackets)... but all the others SHOULD be on the show imo. |
||
|
Kubin |
|||
|
Posts: 157 (10/31/09 1:19 PM) |
I'll replace Aaron with Robb and Nicole with Liz.
|
||
|
cindidindi76 |
|||
|
Posts: 20293 (10/31/09 1:53 PM) Registered User |
Because aren't they filming back to back now???? (I.E 21 and 22 will be filmed in the same spot) I'm curious to see if they continuw doing that, or if it was just some sort of cover for them doing another ASS season in the same spot. |
||
