Rate the seasons from best to worst

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
Buccaneer		#121	[-]
Posts: 258 (09/03/09 3:08 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Good BB9 BB3 BB11 Okay BB7 BB4 BB5 BB10 Sucked BB6 BB8 BB2
Yeaster		#122	[-]
Posts: 7099 (09/03/09 7:08 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Why is everyone rating BB10 is low? That is easily the best season since BB3, end of. Never boring, and the contestants actually weren't completely dispicable for a change. My ranks: BB2 BB3 BB10 The rest. The worst season is clearly BB4, and I'd put this season somewhere around the upper-middle.
Emcee Batley		#123	[-]
Posts: 2018 (09/03/09 8:23 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BB10 was very boring, were we watching the same show? All the drama went out the door from the Final 9 to the Final 7 in a row. Having a bunch of people left in the end who no one really hated was just plain boring. Plus Dan's lines in the DR were SO scripted. They were trying to feed us another Dr. Will for the 10th Anniversary, which is why they only gave them Season 2 and Season 7 to watch Pre-Game, and instead the person who had potential to be the next Dr. Will got scrapped Week 1. So they resorted to Dan, who did play a solid game but shouldn't even be compared to Will. Dan is closer to Drew in gameplay. Memphis is also completely underrated game play just because he was a bore who lost 7-0. He played just as well as Dan did and didn't need a date with Michele to win. Part of me thinks the vote was really 5-2 or 6-1 for Dan and they just paid the other two jurors to change their vote to make BB10 a landmark. With that being said, on with the rankings: Great Seasons: 1. Big Brother 7 - If they cut Erika and Boogie and actually did make it a cast of 12 like it was hyped up to be, we would have had a perfect All-Star cast. Well...even if they just cut Erika. Boogie was at least memorable. This season was amazing to watch unfold as the puppet master was up to his old tricks again and proved that despite there being a new format, Dr. Will could dish it out with the best of them. Stars of the Season: Will Janelle George Danielle James Jase Shame of the Season: Erika Janelle (Yes, both) Howie Diane Nakomis 2. Big Brother 8 - Rigging accusations aside, this season was one of the most talked about and controversial seasons ever and it couldn't have ended better with the star and fan favorite of the season winning against his own daughter. Big Brother 8 was Evel Dick, no one can deny that, if they do then they're just lying to themselves. So it was nice to see the big character of the season go on to win the game. Stars of the Season: Dick Daniele Eric Jessica Jen Amber Shame of the Season: Zach Jameka Dustin 3. Big Brother 2 - Without doubt, this is the "Borneo" of Big Brother. Dr. Will was a genius and the season is one of the best and most entertaining to watch unfold each and every time. Stars of the Season: Will Nicole Monica Hardy Bunky Kent Boogie Shannon Justin Shame of the Season: Krista Autumn 4. Big Brother 3 - Big Brother 3 and Big Brother 2 go hand in hand and was a worthy follow up to an amazing season. Watching Danielle and Jason strategist and dominate the house as well as the crazy antics and arguments of the other houseguests that summer holds a special place in my heart. Stars of the Season: Danielle Jason Amy Marcellas Roddy Gerry Josh Shame of the Season: Chiara Tonya Good Seasons: 5. Big Brother 11 - Even though it's still in progress, it definitely ranks up there with the best of them. Stars of the Season: Jeff Jordan Kevin Michele Casey Russell Ronnie Jessie Shame of the Season: Lydia Natalie 6. Big Brother 5 - The Four Horsemen, Marvin, Holly and Nakomis? Uh fantastic season with a boring winner. Cowboy winning would have been epic. Stars of the Season: Cowboy Diane Nakomis Marvin Twin Beasts - Adria and Natalie Jase Scott Holly Shame of the Season: Karen 7. Big Brother 1 - Why this season is totally dismissed by casual fans is beyond me. Although the show had been less entertaining once Will Mega left and then once Jordan left, it was still worth watching and had a decent group of starter contestants. Eddie, the douchebag of the season, winning because he had one leg was the cherry on top. Stars of the Season: Eddie George Brittany Jordan Will Mega Shame of the Season: Jamie Karen 7. Big Brother 6 - It was the all-time favorite season during it's time but since, the novelty of people going off on each other has worn off. It happens every season now. When are we going to get a calm season of Big Brother without arguments or near fist fights for one week, like in the old days of Big Brother 1-4. I blame this on Jase and Scott from BB5. Anyway, epic cast with a poor ending. Stars of the Season: Janelle Howie James Kaysar Sarah Shame of the Season: Ivette April Jennifer Cappy OK Seasons: 9. Big Brother 9: 'Til Death Do You Part - Having a giant cast and a lame twist doesn't give you kudos right off the bat. But this season is definitely underrated. The game was so poorly played yet so fascinating to watch with this 'Real World'-esque cast. However, if every season was cast and played this way then BB would have been canceled. This season will forever remain the 'red headed step child' season since it was so trashy and aired during the winter. But I think everyone, for the most part, loves it deep down inside. Stars of the Season: Adam Sheila James Matty Amanda Alison Alex Parker Shame of the Season: Ryan Joshua Chelsia Jen Bad Seasons: 10. Big Brother 4 - A poor, ugly and mostly unentertaining cast. This season is memorable for being so awful, even though it brought out a worthy final two, which is rare that we get two deserving finalists. Overall it was mediocre and boring to watch from the second week all the way until the final six or five. Stars of the Season: Jun Alison Erika Robert Jack David Shame of the Season: Jee Nathan Dana Michele 11. Big Brother 10 - As a whole, the season left a bad taste in my mouth and I think I'm not alone. It was hyped up to be an "old school" season with a cast full of strangers who were strategically playing the game unlike BB8 and BB9 which were mostly arguing and bickering with emotion decision making. The season brought us some great villains and some mediocre heros. Many of the DR's felt scripted and it just got boring and tiresome. This was the first season since I began watching with BB2, that I seriously considered to stop watching around the final seven or so. The fact we lost six major characters in the first six weeks, love them or hate them, and got left with a final seven consisting of: Keesha/Michele/Ollie/Jerry/Memphis was awful. Dan was a highlight but even he was boring and fabricated and Renny would get on your nerves on occasion despite being a fun person to root for. The outcome played heavily on the show. Stars of the Season: Dan Renny Libra Jessie Brian Shame of the Season: Keesha Jerry Ollie Michele April
crzypunk2004		#124	[-]
Posts: 4898 (09/03/09 2:13 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Classic BB 1. Big Brother 2 - Monica, Will and Nicole made that season 2. Big Brother 3 - Danielle & Jason, Amy returning, Gerry being the first person to use the veto on someone and Marcellus not using the veto. 3. Big Brother 6 - stars of the season were Janelle, Kaysar, Howie, and Ivette. Good but no classic 4. Big Brother 7 - It was fun seeing some of the greats (Will, Danielle and Janelle) battle it out, even if we had some dumb casting choices (Erika and Boogie). 5. Big Brother 4 - This season is so underrated plus Jun <3 Started out great but then got boring and predictable 6. Big Brother 5 - Loved Nakomis and Diane but after Jase left it became predictable. 7. Big brother 10 - All the interesting people left in the first few week and early jury (Brian, Jesse , and Libra) Meh 8. Big brother 8 - I liked it for the most part but I always wondered what the outcome would have been if America didn't keep Dick in all the damn time. 9. Big Brother 11 - Chima and Russell had their moments but the fan faves turned into annoying idiots towards the end of the game Not so great 10. Big Brother 9 - I really wasn't all that great 11. Big Brother 1 - BORING Last Edited By: crzypunk2004 09/03/09 4:06 PM. Edited 1 times.
BBjXavier		#125	[-]
Posts: 643 (09/03/09 2:13 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. BB6-Half the cast was amazing, half of the casts were assholes. The drama of the power shifting each week was great. Just because every season after it tries to emmulate it doesnt mean it should be condemned, they were the originators. 2. BB2-this season stands the test of time. I didnt watch it when it first aired I watched it sometime after BB6 & it was amazing. Great cast, Dr. Will had amazing gameplay, loved Nicole. 3. BB11-I dont know if I like this season so much because it is airing right now but I have really enjoyed it. I will go ahead and say it, this season possesed my all time favorite HG in Chima. She bought the best drama I have ever seen on the show and on the feeds. She also had the best speech in BB history. No other HG had the show by the balls like Chima. This season got me really into the show & I actually watched feeds again for the first time since Season 6 and this was the first time I have ever watched entire BBAD episodes. 4. BB3-My first season watching, so I am partial to it. 5. BB4-I really dont get all the hate for this season. BB3 was my frist but BB4 is what got me addicted to the show. When Dana was there the season was amazing in that she shook up the game so much and went after that vile $+*% Alison. I liked the Stooges, loved Jun, and loved how the entire house hated the Final 2. This was the first time ever that the entire jury ignored the final 2 after crowning the winner. They all remain seated and didnt congratulate either one of the two finalists and let them walk out of the BB house alone a great ending to a good season. 6. BB10-I like this season because after three really sucky seasons 7-9 they finally went back to an old school format. No couples, lame twists dominated the game. All strangers and this is what I had wanted for a while. No one was vile or disgusting and we had a good first boot as he deserved to go first, a decent enough winner, and best of all Libra. 7. BB7- I see this season as a really bad spin off attempt at Season 6. It's like the producers wanted a repeat of Season 6 and decided to do an All Star season with all of the S6 stars of the show making their glorious return. As with most television spin offs, it wore off it's novelty really fast and with a cast of supporting characters that just wasnt the same as Season 6 this season just fell short. It also had the worst winner in the show's history up until Dick won. 8. BB5-I never really got into this season. I hated Jase, after Holly left the show kinda died. The twin twist bought back some life into it. Just enough to make it somewhat memorable but not one of the best. 9. BB9-Lame couples twist, pretty bad cast, nothing memorable really happened. Not only was this cast Real World-esque it was Real World Las Vegas-esque the season that bought down that franchise to new lows. This season did the same for Big Brother. Thankfully this show seems to have realized trash wasnt the way to go as it has rebounded with two non-trashy shows that still were good. 10. BB8-Worst cast ever, I have never seen such a huge group of followers with no brain power of their own. It was like watching a season full of dumbass cult followers who did everything Evil Dick wanted them to. ED didnt even deserve to be on tv. He is a lowlife disgusting human being who got saved by Grodner from the streets of LA where he was a has been, never was wanna be bad ass with bad tattoos that look gross on his wrinkled old body. Add to all of that the constant rigging of the show (what was the point in watching a rigged season?) and this asshole's c.unt of a duaghter, and not one but two very annoying gay guys, an ugly ass cry baby, a jewish dork who had no balls, I could go on and on about these losers. This was the first time ever I had stopped watching a Big Brother season, I stuck with every other season no matter how bad it got or how bad I was pissed at who was winning (IE BB6). This season disgusted me so much I couldnt watch it any longer and if it hadnt been for Jen I probably wouldnt have watched as much as I did. Worst season ever. Last Edited By: BBjXavier 09/03/09 2:44 PM. Edited 1 times.
wooppeee		#126	[-]
Posts: 188 (09/03/09 2:35 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Good points from y'all. For me this season was the worst, I get the feeds every year since BB2. This time I was away, and watched the first show . When I saw Jesse, I first thought- yuk I ain't getting the feeds til he's gone. Then seeing Ronnie and his gross body/face gestures and what a big BITCH, I mean real bitch > Chima is...well her exit says it all. <That was the best part of TV baby! Nat never shuts up, she's like that pup that chases the bulldog on Bugs Bunny...anyone? anyone? only the begining of that 'toon Lucky me I missed out on the "pitching the tent" show with Lydia. Thanks all for the updates and such, I couldn't go the whole season away from it all.
KellysMomCalledMeFine		#127	[-]
Posts: 2635 (09/03/09 2:51 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	AMAZING <33 1. BB7 - JANELLE OWNAGE x infinity 2. BB6 - JANELLE OWNAGE 3. BB10 - <33 Dan, Keesh, Renny, Memp! 4. BB8 - Donatos were great entertainment and I <3 Jessica/Jen! 5. BB2 - Dr Delicious 6. BB3 - Danielle - THE BLACK WIDOW, FOLKS! The Good <3 7. BB4 - Alison's constant hook ups! 8. BB5 - Jase and Drew should've made pretty babies together. Marvin/Cowboy/Twins shit made this suck, though. The awful </333 9. BB1 10. BB9 - HATE. ManBearPig FAIL. This year will end up at #9 if Michele, Kev, Jordan or Jeff win. If Natalie wins, it will be DEAD.FUCKING.LAST. Last Edited By: KellysMomCalledMeFine 09/03/09 2:53 PM. Edited 1 times.
Gojoseon		#128	[-]
Posts: 146 (09/03/09 3:03 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Favorite 1. BB 4 2. BB 10 3. BB 7 Good 4. BB 3 5. BB 6 6. BB 9 7. BB 5 8. BB 11 Bad 9. BB 8 10. BB 2
Riff		#129	[-]
Posts: 3689 (09/15/09 9:26 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Good from start to finish 1. BB3 - Any season with a hot bartender underdog winner works for me. The first season with good production values and addictive feeds. The cast had great chemistry and, plus, they got naked all the time. 2. BB6 - The first season with big fireworks. The live audience added some much-needed energy that had been missing. 3. BB10 - Deserving final 2. Dominant alliance were fun to watch together. Unlike the other Grodner/Shapiro-less seasons, no blatant rigging. 4. BB2 - The show itself wasn't particularly well-produced at this point, but I liked the cast dynamics. Will was always an enjoyable watch. Had moments 5. BB9 - It was like the trainwreck you couldn't look away from, between the gross, skeevy cast of the finest gutter trash on the planet and all the technical glitches on every single live show. With only 3 or 4 exceptions, everybody on it seemed incredibly fake. Like they were all actors using the thing as their audition reel or something. 6. BB5 - There was times I really liked it, but was meh a lot of the time. The feeds were dull as dishwater after the first few weeks. 7. BB7 - It had a happy ending. Because Janelle, Howie and Kaysar lost all over again. But I didn't really care to see any of these people again. Bad 8. BB4 - Poorly-cast, no real chemistry (that's pretty sad considering the 5 exes twist), season fell apart VERY quickly. 9. BB1 - Just an all-around misfire, proving once and for all why viewers shouldn't be allowed to vote period. Burn the master tapes 10. BB8 - The only good thing about this season was the house. Disgusting rigathon with a vile Final 2 who should both be burned at the stake. Truly unwatchable. 11. BB11 (a.k.a. The Jeff and Jordan Show) - Racist season. Nonstop rigging for Bigot Ken and Barbie. Total joke of a winner who was clearly given "help" during the last competition. Jury votes made no sense. The early episodes were basically awful, with very poor editing early on that left non-feed watchers bewildered as to what was even going on. Burn it. And Fire Grodhog already.
Blueberry.celebprowresting		#130	[-]
Posts: 1310 (09/15/09 9:27 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Season 11 would have been better had Kevin won but he didnt so BB11 is low on my list, VERY LOW!
OaktownFunk		#131	[-]
Posts: 4057 (09/15/09 9:35 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	-If the Seasons were Houseguests- the final 2 1 Season 2 2 Season 6 makin' the jury 3 Season 7 all stars 4 Season 3 5 Season 10 6 Season 11 7 Season 8 8 Season 9 9 Season 5 pre-jury boots 10 Season 4 11 Season 1
PleasantMama		#132	[-]
Posts: 2727 (09/15/09 9:37 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	YAY! BB3 BB2 BB5 BB4 OKAY BB7 BB6 BLAH BB8-BB11 SHIT BB1
irootforthegayguy		#133	[-]
Posts: 214 (09/15/09 11:33 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BB3 - Quintessential Big Brother season. It had everything that makes up a great Big Brother season - decent but not over-the-top strategy, great characters, people to root for, villains rising then crashing and burning, romance, good twists, good results, nice pace -- it's just the ending that people always trip over. Eh. The rest of the season was great and Lisa was a sweetheart! BB4 - Very underrated, in my eyes. I feel like this is the least cartoonish Big Brother will ever be (despite such a zany twist) - not that everyone was super mature, but the way things ended up - it did feel very grounded and 'real'. Plus Jun is a !*!##!+ - and that was the best final 2 ever despite the lamest (yet hilarious) jury. Yeah it was very slow but I like slow burns better than things losing steam. BB2 - Like someone said above, it was the 'Borneo' of Big Brother. The foundation the franchise is made of. Nicole is still very underrated as a player and Hardy is very underrated as the perfect BB villain arch. BB5 - Kind of underrated? It was my first Big Brother season so I might be biased but it was a really fun rollercoaster ride. The power was never really in anyone's hands for that long (which, thank god, because I remember fearing that the Four Horsemen were going to reign supreme for the whole season) and the strategy was pretty decent. The twists ruined it - those fucking twinbeasts. But, bias again, watching Diane kind of find her way through everything only to have Drew be the biggest dick of BB history kind of ruins the season as a whole. It was a fun ride, though, and the people that were cast on that show were pretty unique for BB. BB11 - Not that bad, not that bad. Sure, the outcomes sucked as fuck, but it was very intriguing watching it all unfold. I liked not being so invested since everyone was so unrootable. It was a weird mix of people and a weird mix of events but it seemed, besides the rigging, kind of retro in a way. BB7 - SOOOO much potential. It kills me sometimes thinking of how great it could have been. BB6 - Overrated! The house so painstakingly divided was so boring, especially because I did not like either side that much. Plus, it made Howie's dumbass fucking move even more fucking stupid since it was so divided. Maggie was one conniving witch coven leader, I'll give her that. It was fun seeing BB contestants finally just start to lash out each other without any regrets (though it probably lead to Ivette losing) BB10 - It was ... alright. It was kind of similar to BB11, in respects, but the villains were so ... boring and not fleshed out enough to actually enjoy rooting against them. There was no real pleasure seeing Dan/Keesha/Renny/Memphis make it to the end because like ... whatever. Plus, Dan's voice was annoying as fuuuuck. BB8 - Very strong characters, brought out a lot of emotional investment within me - but it's so tainted. Fuck the Donato's. BB9 - TRASHHHHHHH. I hate the school of thought that the winner dictates how well the season was, but some seasons are just so hard to not associate them with some undeserving fuck winning (Lisa & Drew, and then Boogie, come to mind instantly - probably Jordan too)

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Rate the seasons from best to worst

Quick Reply