SurvivorFanGP wrote:Excuse me sir, I don't believe we've met. =O
spnintendo wrote:Since when did chu become so "pro-male"
Jason <333
Ruh roh, there's only two guys left in your F8. One of them ftw. =O
![]()
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
spnintendo |
|||
SurvivorFanGP wrote:Excuse me sir, I don't believe we've met. =O |
|||
Mikester |
|||
|
There is nobody in All-Stars whose ranking improved because of All-Stars (except maybe George since he wouldn't be on this without All-Stars). It brought
almost everyone's down or left it the same. Such a horrible season.
|
|||
SurvivorFanGP |
|||
spnintendo wrote: Maybe I didn't notice as much previously =O *gasp* I bet you were rooting for the guys instead of the BWB in FvF =P
Last Edited By: SurvivorFanGP
06/25/09 7:32 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
That argument never made sense to me, Mike. Not only do you get a second chance to see them play the game, you get to see the people from a different angle. Of course BB is for the most part pulpy entertainment, but at some point you might say "Hey, this is occasionally an interesting social experiment". So I like watching All Stars seasons. |
|||
spnintendo |
|||
SurvivorFanGP wrote:Actually all the guys in FvF were douches or dumbasses >_> I was saddened by Eric's departure though. |
|||
DAnn Coulter |
|||
|
Am I the only one who thinks Jason lives in the closet???
PS: I also liked everyone much less on AS than I did in their original seasons...
Last Edited By: DAnn Coulter
06/25/09 7:46 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Mikester |
|||
Dr Will Hatch two point oh wrote:What argument? That I liked them less the second time around? You're right, it's like getting to see a different side of the their personality. In the case of the players in All-Stars, I liked them all less the second time around. It's not really an argument. |
|||
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Anytime you make a claim, you make an argument. It's no big deal.
|
|||
Mikester |
|||
|
But I have no idea what you're trying to say lulz
|
|||
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
That I loved All Stars and that Dr Will actually improved his standing by proving a previous winner had a legitimate shot with the right cast. <3
|
|||
Paris Hilton |
|||
|
I only saw parts of the earlier seasons before BB4, but in All-Stars not a single on of them got better imo.
|
|||
Mikester |
|||
|
These updates keep getting harder and harder…
#8: Roddy Mancuso, Big Brother 3 Uh-oh more man-slaughter! Roddy is another one of my beloved Big Brother 3 contestants. He's probably not as well-known or well-liked as Danielle, Jason, Marcellas, or Amy, but he beats out all but Danielle & Amy in my rankings. I actually considered putting Roddy higher but I had to settle for #8 because I couldn't push anyone below him. Roddy didn't start out as one of my favorites, because he was a part of the six alliance and I was rooting for the other side. But he slowly started to grow on me. In the third week, Roddy won Head of Household and nominated Marcellas against Amy, which was horrible for me because I loved Amy and Marcellas. Still, I came around to liking Roddy much more that week since he proved himself to be a pretty hardcore player. Roddy & Chiara's showmance wasn't a very popular one but I actually liked it a lot. It was funny to watch him try to use her, but get so frustrated with her behavior that he couldn't. In the fifth week, Chiara nominated Roddy against Josh. I don't really remember why but it seemed stupid. Roddy stayed 5-0, and when Amy returned that same night, the hate that I held for Roddy diminished because she was back. Roddy was nominated against Chiara by Amy that following week, and was all set to be evicted. Danielle wanted Roddy out badly, and Marcellas, Jason, and Lisa agreed that he was the bigger threat, but Amy's intense hatred for Chiara made everyone feel terrible about evicting Roddy, so Roddy stayed. Yay! Roddy stays, Amy gets her way, so it was an awesome week for me. It looked like Roddy would be doomed the next week when Danielle's closest ally Jason won HoH. But Roddy worked Jason, hard. He used their friendship to manipulate Jason (who actually cried) to not nominate him. Finally Marcellas won HoH and got the job done, and Roddy ended the game in sixth place. But he didn't go down without a fight. Early on in the game, Amy agreed to use the PoV on Roddy if the situation ever arose, and what do you know, the week Roddy was set to go, Amy won the PoV. He worked her hard to get her to use it on him, but she didn't. Sad. A lot of people compare Roddy to Dr. Will, but without the act. I disagree because Dr. Will is basically his act, but I think Roddy was an awesome player and Danielle's only real competition the entire season (unless you count the fluke of Lisa beating her in the end.) Danielle also referred to Roddy as the "devil" because of how cunning he was. A lot of people referred to him as a sociopath but I don't think so, he was just playing the game. |
|||
WylDawg |
|||
|
Roddy is a God. Too bad he happens to be on the same show as Dr. Will who is a higher diety.
But he's exactly how I like my alpha males, grown up and smart. He would've been awsome on Survivor. I actually considered putting Roddy higher but I had to settle for #8 because I couldn't push anyone below him. Yes, Jen. |
|||
Mikester |
|||
|
I'm just warning some people right now that the ending to this ranking is not going to be very popular. Some of you may want to stop following it =O
|
|||
solesurvivor01 |
|||
|
There are only a couple of meh people left, so the end can't be THAT bad. Roddy was kinda meh too, IMO, but only in comparison to some of the other people
left (not Jen, though). Also, Roddy was on a season with a lot of likable people, and it just so happened that a bunch of them made it to the end. Lisa,
Dani, Jason, and Amy are quite possibly one of my favorite final fours on any reality show I've ever seen.
|
|||
Oaf |
|||
|
Roddy I thought was one of the smartest people they ever cast on the show, but on a personal level, I couldn't stand him when the season was over. For a
guy who always used his charm to get his way, it was aggravating and kind of creepy when he tried to present himself as righteous.
I'm pulling for Danielle and Jen. Danielle, because she would have been one of the greatest reality winners ever if the jury hadn't been able to see footage from the show before voting. Jen, because it was painful to watch the abuse she received from Dick - it got me totally emotionally invested in her, even though her shallowness turned me off to her at first. Also, I learned to appreciate her randomness as the season progressed. |
|||
DAnn Coulter |
|||
WylDawg wrote: That pretty much says it all. He's one of my all time favorites because of how mature and intelligent he is.. Probably the only male HG I'd be able to get along with great in RL. Glad he didn't do AS because he's way too good for that shit... Oh and he's like a million times better than that overrated little shit Dr. Will. Roddy <3333333333333333 Mikester wrote: At this point as long as it's not Will or his whore from that season, I'll be fine with anyone else getting #1 :)... even Amy |
|||
Mikester |
|||
|
Uhm, actually, Will was Shannon's whore. Re-watch the season. The bitch had him WRAPPED.
|
|||
WylDawg |
|||
At this point as long as it's not Will or his whore from that season Yeah, Dr. Will being at number 1 makes no sense whatever, but Jen Johnson at number 1 would be the perfect, most rational ending to this list. |
|||
solesurvivor01 |
|||
WylDawg wrote:And here I was thinking you had bad taste, Wyl. Jen winning this would be major |
|||