allymw wrote:
AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote:
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
allymw wrote: |
|||
dapa091 |
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote:SHUT THE FUCK UP |
|||
Coachocd |
|||
|
By the way, not all the acting is bad on this show. Go watch the actress who plays Robin kick butt in this week's episode.
|
|||
SurvivorArctic |
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote:I know :) That's why you still have your nuts |
|||
myopics |
|||
|
Are we still doing spoiler tags?
|
|||
superkyle |
|||
|
I miss GiGi, and I hope she survives to the end as well. |
|||
crazy1500 |
|||
pjadedd wrote: |
|||
Fever |
|||
|
With so many pages of spoilers lately, I'm guessing that something big will happen this episode! Although I'm dying to know, I'm trying to resist
temptation. After all, it's Saturday already ... Anyway, I haven't changed my mind from what I said some 50 pages pages back. I still think that Henry
is the killer, that he is a very clever psycho who has relished killing people long before this return to the island, that he has one or two accomplices or
helpers (the main one being Nikki), that when they were younger Nikki and he were a deranged love couple doing dangerous things, etc., etc. And if there is a
third accomplice, I'm still keeping an eye on the mysterious gardener. I've considered Jimmy and Maggie, too, but only in passing. And Cal, too, since
the first episode, but no, I've settled for Henry and Nikki and maybe the gardener. From reading this week's and last week's pages, it seems that
lots of people have gotten into the Maggie wagon. I highly doubt that is it she. That's because it wouldn't be hip for her to be the killer! I mean,
when I saw the cast, she was the one who I chose right away ... but afterwards I realized the reason why I had picked her: she would be the likeliest killer in
a TRADITIONAL mystery novel in the Agatha Christie or Conan Doyle mold. I just don't think that a modern series like this one would want to revert to
traditional molds. For people saying that Henry would be too obvious, maybe it would be to you, and to guys who post in sites like this one, but not
necessarily to the more average viewers. I bet that many average viewers didn't suspect Henry at all until his most incriminating scene - the killing of
JD. And even that scene can be interpreted as either proof or denial that he is the murderer. Folks who don't believe so might perhaps feel that something
isn't quite right, but will still say that he couldn't possibly kill his own brother (nevermind that he's adopted, that we've seen Henry's
violent streak with JD before, and that psychos won't necessarily restrain themselves from killing family). In my mind, the killing of JD was totally
unplanned by Henry, and it happened in the heat of the moment, only because JD caught Henry (or Nikki or both). It was so unplanned that Henry had no time to
come up with an alibis or a logical explanation! Here's something about which I'm wondering, though: were the scratches in Henry's face and arm
from fingernails (as is long, female fingernails)? It kind of looked like that to me, but I didn't feel completely sure. If so, I'll have to come up
with some crazy story i to explain this -- like, Nikki scratching Henry during a fight over the killing of JD. Damn. I'm not half done, and this is long
enough already that almost nobody will read it ... Well, just one question, then: can anyone talk about Henry's and JD's parents? I think I read that
they were teachers and that they died in a car accident. (Accident? Yeah right.) We also know that Harkin was visited by the father (and by JD) when Harkin was
at the hospital. Is that all? Nothing known about the mother? And is Henry supposed to be the adopted one, or is it JD? I didn't completely hear that
conversation that Henry had about this with the sheriff. About that conversation - there was "pregnant silence" and a "meaningful look"
exchanged at some point, right after Henry or the sheriff said something about Henry's parents. I read it as, "there is something painful that we both
know about, and that for the well-being of either one or both of us, must not be verbally expressed." (To me, this could be about Henry being
Wakefield's son, and about the sheriff knowledge that Henry is his daughter' brother. So many things point to Henry as being Henry's child that
I'll be surprised if that doesn't turn out to be the case.)
|
|||
pjadedd |
|||
crazy1500 wrote:I didn't have a reference from Clue, so I had to go with Aunt Jackie. |
|||
Fever |
|||
|
Shoo. Why did the message above came all together as one endless paragraph??? As if it wasn't long enough already that nobody was likely to read it!!!! Can
somebody tell me how to break into paragraphs?
|
|||
The Heartbreak Yid |
|||
novaya wrote: Seems to make sense. |
|||
tullfan2 |
|||
|
|
|||
taigark |
|||
|
Wait, now there's a 14th episode? I know Wikipedia isn't reliable, but it will suck if its true. That means this show would have lasted 15 weeks
instead of the original 13 weeks.
|
|||
tullfan2 |
|||
taigark wrote: There will only be 13 episodes. I just checked the CBS online schedule. On July 4th, an episode of Harper's Island will be shown but it will be a rerun of 'Whap', the premiere episode. I expect that the final 2 episodes will be shown on Jully 11th when the series is scheduled to end.
Last Edited By: tullfan2
06/20/09 8:53 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
GoHomeAndEatYoRice |
|||
|
Posts: 870 (06/20/09 9:58 AM) |
On the last episode, it will be a 2 hour thing.
First Part is Gasp and the other is Sigh. Or other way around. Not Sure. |
||
loveski |
|||
|
I wish everybody would narrow it down to 4 or 5 sentence theories. My eyes are glazing over all the essays on this show. Though I am amused that it has incited
this much interest.
|
|||
GoHomeAndEatYoRice |
|||
|
Posts: 872 (06/20/09 10:10 AM) |
Ok, here is what most people think.
A. Booth is alive. B. Henry is the killer. and, that is what the most talk is about, non-spoiler wise. |
||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
GoHomeAndEatYoRice wrote: Actually most think Booth is dead. 2-3 people just keep bring it up over and over again. http://www.survivorsucks.com/topic/53003?page=1 |
|||
Fishy Taffy |
Has anybody ever considered... | ||
|
Maybe Booth IS alive but...he just left.
Perhaps he is like me and feels awkward in a tux and took the opportunity to skip out. |
|||
LPMA |
|||
|
Are we really getting a 2 hour finale? Was it planned this way all along? If so, I fully expect a big reveal where EVERYTHING will be explained.
Last Edited By: LPMA
06/20/09 11:00 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||