Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
AlwaysAwesomeAdam		#4001	[-]
Posts: 3245 (06/19/09 9:23 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Coachocd wrote: AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: I bet in school even after the teacher told you the answer wasn't A you still picked A Oh, I listened to my teachers. I just didn't listen to the emotionally disturbed guy in the back who had a pet spider in his shirt pocket who told me the answer wasn't A. No wonder you're an idiot you have MPD.
Coachocd		#4002	[-]
Posts: 7734 (06/19/09 9:33 PM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: No wonder you're an idiot you have MPD. Which voice in your head told you that? Obviously the one that tells you to be an a-hole.
ILoveCurling		#4003	[-]
Posts: 96 (06/19/09 9:44 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I love being a lurker in this thread cause I really like the show a lot. I like reading everyone's ideas and opinions, even some that may be very out there. But man this is getting so petty in here. I know this is sucks and that's the spirit of the board. But I keep thinking that the next post is going to contain "I'm rubber you're glue what you says bounces of me and sticks to you". Last Edited By: ILoveCurling 06/19/09 9:49 PM. Edited 1 times.
joeyrd1027		#4004	[-]
Posts: 759 (06/19/09 9:53 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	iismepeter wrote: I'm starting to think we're WAYYY overthinking this. I'm suspecting a dumbass ending. I've kinda of thought the same thing from episode 5, when the Booth conspiracy theories started popping up. Prefer to keep it simple instead of this incredibly complex stuff that doesn't really make sense such as Henry rigging the docks to blow 7 years ago or Jimmy being incest buddies with Abby, or even that Wakefield didn't kill anyone 7 years ago and it was his accomplice. Wakefield being framed for the murders is pretty improbable. I was finally accepting the fact that Booth was dead but then the episode last week changed my mind. They did not have to show us Cal asking for the 2 units of blood for the Sheriff. Little clinics like that one don't usually keep blood on hand. Cal could have just as easily cleansed & packed the wound, treated him for infection then called for air-vac to the mainland. Well the Sheriff was bleeding for practically hours. A giant spike to the leg that he pried out himself definitely left a big enough hole to lose a lot of blood. I think Harkin even said that he's gonna lose the leg if he didn't get him to a hospital. More blood for the Sheriff was kind of obviously necessary. I really doubt that he could simply put a bandage on it and say off you go. And don't forgot that all communication to basically anywhere on the mainland was destroyed. I'm rubber you're glue what you says bounces of me and sticks to you Last Edited By: joeyrd1027 06/19/09 9:57 PM. Edited 1 times.
allymw		#4005	[-]
Posts: 164 (06/19/09 9:54 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: I bet in school even after the teacher told you the answer wasn't A you still picked A Spoiler [+] For pretty much the only person here who thinks Trish is the killer, you're being a little over the top here... he's not the only one who thinks Booth is alive. I'm kind of in the middle, but calling someone stupid or telling them to leave the thread because you don't agree with their opinion is just obnoxious. Can you just let other people have their opinions? I personally don't agree with your insightful assessment that "Madison burned a snail, most children burn ants, therefore Madison does not want to hurt her aunt and that's one of the reasons Trish is the killer." that you've posted a few times already... and despite how retarded i think that theory is, I and most of the people in this thread have enough decency to just voice our opinion on why we think this or why we don't think that.... calling someone stupid for their theory is just annoying and doesn't add anything to the debate on who the killer is. It just makes you look obnoxious.
Miles Edgeworth		#4006	[-]
Posts: 1738 (06/19/09 10:21 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	novaya wrote: iismepeter wrote: I'm starting to think we're WAYYY overthinking this. I'm suspecting a dumbass ending. If you believe in the POWAR of WikiVandalism, someone pwnt the Harper's Island death toll page all the way to the finale (who dies/lives/is the killer). I think it sounds about right, but whatever. POTENTIAL SPOILERS: http://en.wikipedia.org/w...land&oldid=297463714 I am so thinking of inserting booth as the killer for laffos
Tiki Lou		#4007	[-]
Posts: 514 (06/19/09 10:25 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	novaya wrote: iismepeter wrote: I'm starting to think we're WAYYY overthinking this. I'm suspecting a dumbass ending. If you believe in the POWAR of WikiVandalism, someone pwnt the Harper's Island death toll page all the way to the finale (who dies/lives/is the killer). I think it sounds about right, but whatever. POTENTIAL SPOILERS: http://en.wikipedia.org/w...land&oldid=297463714 If the above link is true, then Spoiler [+] that's exactly how I want it to end. One couple has the killer, one couple gets seperated by a death and one couple makes it to the end, and hopefully it is Cal and Chloe, the only couple I really give a shit about. And I predict that in the end, they'll just go to Vegas and get married by Elvis. Last Edited By: Tiki Lou 06/19/09 10:28 PM. Edited 1 times.
Hippochinfat		#4008	[-]
Posts: 52 (06/19/09 10:29 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	tullfan2 wrote: Spoiler [+] There are still 3 scenes left in the season preview from the end of episode 2 that haven't come up yet. 1. Danny lights a candle in the church ("I think that we need a prayer") 2. A woman drops a glass of wine. 3. Abby hits someone with the back side of a gun Spoiler [+] The second one happened this episode, Madison dropped a glass of something when Maggie appeared in front of the window.
AlwaysAwesomeAdam		#4009	[-]
Posts: 3246 (06/19/09 10:56 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	allymw wrote: AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: I bet in school even after the teacher told you the answer wasn't A you still picked A Spoiler [+] For pretty much the only person here who thinks Trish is the killer, you're being a little over the top here... he's not the only one who thinks Booth is alive. I'm kind of in the middle, but calling someone stupid or telling them to leave the thread because you don't agree with their opinion is just obnoxious. Can you just let other people have their opinions? I personally don't agree with your insightful assessment that "Madison burned a snail, most children burn ants, therefore Madison does not want to hurt her aunt and that's one of the reasons Trish is the killer." that you've posted a few times already... and despite how retarded i think that theory is, I and most of the people in this thread have enough decency to just voice our opinion on why we think this or why we don't think that.... calling someone stupid for their theory is just annoying and doesn't add anything to the debate on who the killer is. It just makes you look obnoxious. Spoiler [+] For starters my suspect is still alive and has had a heavy edit throughout the series. Booth is random and barely had one episode of air time. 2ndly, I'm not picking somebody who's dead as the killer and then saying they are an accomplice. Once you're dead you are dead. So I think my Trish theory is a little less retarded than the Booth one which you clearly believe more.
Coachocd		#4010	[-]
Posts: 7735 (06/19/09 11:00 PM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] If Jimmy is Wakefield's son, explaining why he may have let him live, was the reason Jimmy was a mess when Abby left wasn't because of romantic heartbreak, but because his sister was gone? Here's a thin theory, but since everything we thought we knew is sort of thrown out, couldn't it also be possible that Wakefield's son is not the one doing the killings now, but using the legend, having no idea the real Wakefield is still alive? What if Jimmy is Wakefield's son, but Henry is the one using the Wakefield legend to kill people? Probably not, but I'll throw it out there. Note, Jimmy doesn't seem to be a computer whiz. Theoretically, if Henry (or anyone else) is the killer, they are finding time to slip away and kill these people over here on Harper's Globe and upload videos to scare Robin. I guess that's what they call the willing suspension of disbelief.
Coachocd		#4011	[-]
Posts: 7736 (06/19/09 11:04 PM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: allymw wrote: Spoiler [+] For pretty much the only person here who thinks Trish is the killer, you're being a little over the top here... he's not the only one who thinks Booth is alive. I'm kind of in the middle, but calling someone stupid or telling them to leave the thread because you don't agree with their opinion is just obnoxious. Can you just let other people have their opinions? I personally don't agree with your insightful assessment that "Madison burned a snail, most children burn ants, therefore Madison does not want to hurt her aunt and that's one of the reasons Trish is the killer." that you've posted a few times already... and despite how retarded i think that theory is, I and most of the people in this thread have enough decency to just voice our opinion on why we think this or why we don't think that.... calling someone stupid for their theory is just annoying and doesn't add anything to the debate on who the killer is. It just makes you look obnoxious. Spoiler [+] For starters my suspect is still alive and has had a heavy edit throughout the series. Booth is random and barely had one episode of air time. 2ndly, I'm not picking somebody who's dead as the killer and then saying they are an accomplice. Once you're dead you are dead. So I think my Trish theory is a little less retarded than the Booth one which you clearly believe more. Don't bother, Alleymw. He's picked fights with others on this thread like ATF. You obviously cannot reason with him. Just look at his avatar. Gee. Watching someone fall down and get hurt. Ha, ha. ha. He's so obnoxious he is probably one of those people who laughed at handicapped kids in school. Last Edited By: Coachocd 06/19/09 11:06 PM. Edited 1 times.
SurvivorArctic		#4012	[-]
Posts: 18131 (06/19/09 11:08 PM) Not a team player Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] Trish is not the killer, of that I am certain. WHo the killer actually is...I'm still torn but I am convinced it is a pair of people doing the deeds. Than again, I am not emotionally invested in the outcome, I just enjoy a good whodunit.
AlwaysAwesomeAdam		#4013	[-]
Posts: 3247 (06/19/09 11:14 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Coachocd wrote: AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: allymw wrote: Spoiler [+] For pretty much the only person here who thinks Trish is the killer, you're being a little over the top here... he's not the only one who thinks Booth is alive. I'm kind of in the middle, but calling someone stupid or telling them to leave the thread because you don't agree with their opinion is just obnoxious. Can you just let other people have their opinions? I personally don't agree with your insightful assessment that "Madison burned a snail, most children burn ants, therefore Madison does not want to hurt her aunt and that's one of the reasons Trish is the killer." that you've posted a few times already... and despite how retarded i think that theory is, I and most of the people in this thread have enough decency to just voice our opinion on why we think this or why we don't think that.... calling someone stupid for their theory is just annoying and doesn't add anything to the debate on who the killer is. It just makes you look obnoxious. Spoiler [+] For starters my suspect is still alive and has had a heavy edit throughout the series. Booth is random and barely had one episode of air time. 2ndly, I'm not picking somebody who's dead as the killer and then saying they are an accomplice. Once you're dead you are dead. So I think my Trish theory is a little less retarded than the Booth one which you clearly believe more. Don't bother, Alleymw. He's picked fights with others on this thread like ATF. You obviously cannot reason with him. Just look at his avatar. Gee. Watching someone fall down and get hurt. Ha, ha. ha. He's so obnoxious he is probably one of those people who laughed at handicapped kids in school. I don't know who ATF even is. Nor do I remember him. But I find it funny you want to poke fun at my avi when your's is fucking Snoopy in a pilot's hat. If you ask me that just screams shinny ball chaser. Now go put on your Pooh onesie and call it a night.
SurvivorArctic		#4014	[-]
Posts: 18132 (06/19/09 11:16 PM) Not a team player Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	oh shut up. seriously.
AlwaysAwesomeAdam		#4015	[-]
Posts: 3249 (06/19/09 11:21 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Old man.
SurvivorArctic		#4016	[-]
Posts: 18133 (06/19/09 11:22 PM) Not a team player Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	yeah. oooooookay!
GorillaDust		#4017	[-]
Posts: 205 (06/19/09 11:24 PM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	mundo446 wrote: Spoiler [+] Shane definetly dies next week. Hes getting the redemption arc, and is going to die sacrificing his life for someone or even the whole group. Spoiler [+] You could make an even stronger argument for Sully dying soon because of his redemption arc. Sully started the series as Cal's enemy, and this past episode (concluding next episode, I assume) he saves Cal's life. This last episode, he has also sacrificed his own safety by crossing the island to save the others, which is the opposite of what asshole Sully was trying to do a few episodes ago by fleeing the island while Madison's life was at stake. I think Shane is completing his redemption arc, but so is Sully, tenfold. Also, FWIW, most of the people who are proclaiming that Booth is still alive are only saying it's a possibility. Those who think it's not even an option are just being stubborn. Most of those who are saying it's a possibility aren't insulting other people's intelligence (unless they're provoked). Why do the Booth is dead supporters have to be so aggressive? Last Edited By: GorillaDust 06/20/09 1:52 PM. Edited 1 times.
AlwaysAwesomeAdam		#4018	[-]
Posts: 3250 (06/19/09 11:24 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	SurvivorArctic wrote: yeah. oooooookay! You know I like you.
Coachocd		#4019	[-]
Posts: 7737 (06/19/09 11:27 PM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Here's something to add to the Henry pile: From the Harper's Globe Wiki: "Henry currently lives in Seattle and owns a multi-media company." As someone who owns a multi-media company in Seattle (probably with Microsoft or Yahoo as a client), it would mean he is savvy enough to be the only uploading all the videos for Harper's Globe and he probably knows the technology to control (or jam) cell phone access.
allymw		#4020	[-]
Posts: 165 (06/19/09 11:34 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: Spoiler [+] For starters my suspect is still alive and has had a heavy edit throughout the series. Booth is random and barely had one episode of air time. 2ndly, I'm not picking somebody who's dead as the killer and then saying they are an accomplice. Once you're dead you are dead. So I think my Trish theory is a little less retarded than the Booth one which you clearly believe more. Spoiler [+] Dead is dead does not really apply to Wakefield now does it? I agree that it would really kind of suck to have Booth as a killer, but they brought back one dead guy, it wouldn't surprise me at all if they brought back another.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

Quick Reply