2. Adam--interesting performance, took a 30 year old song and made it (kind of) current. B+
3. Matt--the judges panned him for mixing it up. Wait, isn't that what they normally tell you to do? B
4. Scott--clumsy, but heartfelt. C+
5. Allison--why are the judges critiquing her outfit? this is American Idol, not America's Top Model! C-
6. Gokey--over the top and hammy. typical Gokey performance. C-
7. Lil--when will contestants learn? no one does Celine and gets away with it! boring karaoke. D+
8. Anoop--the dog falters tonight. plus he talked back to the judges. not a good sign. D
9. Megan--I like this girl, but not tonight. D-
Brain/Heart: Gokey, Anoop, Megan going home.
Gut: Lil, Anoop, Megan going home.

















