I think it should be JAMES only because ERIK gave up the immunity for a strategic (stupid) purpose. He wants to prove to Cirie that he can be trusted and he wanted to get Nat & Cirie on his side. Yeah, it was stupid, but still, it was a strategic (stupid) move.
While JAMES on the other hand, had two immunity idols, which will expire by the next two tribal councils, choose to not use the idol for no reason at all.
I think JAMES's move which was no move was stupider than ERIK's.
What do you think guys?




















