| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
kmill |
|||
|
By the time this list is done, BB10 will be over.
|
|||
WylDawg |
|||
|
Can't believe Sharon is there. The only thing Sharon has taught us is that if you shut the hell up, you can prolong your stay by 3 extra weeks. And it
helps tremendously if your alliance-mates are unbearable douchebags.
|
|||
finishthemoff |
|||
WylDawg wrote: In other word, she is Colleen of her season.
|
|||
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor |
|||
By the time this list is done, BB10 will be over.Sorry, it's been real hectic. I'm moving to the East Coast on Monday so it's been really busy lately. I'll see if I can get some stuff up between now and tomorrow. If not, I'll have some downtime when I arrive there, so this list will be updated, two or three at a time, and finish within a week. |
|||
kmill |
|||
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor wrote: It's ok, I'm just interested in seeing how this list will turn out. |
|||
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor |
|||
|
20. Drew Daniel, BB5 (Score: 103.5)
In Favor: Read up pre-game on how to tell if someone was lying... Against: ...Yet believed the Twin-Beastsesses when they feigned undying loyalty to the cause of Jase & Co. In Favor: Joined a four-man alliance that could've dominated the whole house... Against: ...had they not voted out Holly which in turn let the rest of the cards fall thereafter. In Favor: Used his years of straight voyeurism to form a showmance that won him the game despite his obvious gayness, Against: but could havve lost everything by the way he handled her exit. Should've set up Cowboy for the HOH win, guaranteeing him Diane's vote. In Favor: Was a challenge winning machine who Against: Unfortuntately let the brother-sister duo go a bit too far into the game for comfort. Blood lines are hard to erase. I really don't know what else to say about Drew. He made some pathetic mistakes near the start which led to an avalanche of t.ears. After, he revitalized his game thanks to an under-the-cover handjob and played the best of anyone from the mid-way point on, proving himself a master at working his way into a new alliance after being part of such a douchebaggy one. Personally, I don't think anyone's ever pulled off the art of jumping from one side to the other in a game with two factions so diametrically opposed. Does he deserve his place here? Probably, although he could be five spaces too high or low. There's strong arguments from either side.
Last Edited By: SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor
08/19/08 1:34 PM.
Edited 2 times.
|
|||
kmill |
|||
|
Drew wasn't THAT bad of a player. Definitely better than Sharon and Jessica, though.
|
|||
GnarlsInCharge |
|||
|
To the other voters Even if you thought he was one of the shittiest winners he should at least be in the top 10. I still don't get why people say putting up Holly was a bad move? Had he nominated one of the other females in the house or Will, the second Will or a female other than Holly were to win HOH it would have been Drew/Jase on the block instead of Jase/Scott. Should he really have played as if the horsemen were gonna win every HOH in the game ? People seem to be fickle when it comes to big brother strategy, In BB5 Drew was considered a strategically inept player for playing a game reliant on the power in the house shifting btwn different alliances every week. The next year in BB6 everyone plays exactly the opposite of Drew everyone still complains how strategically inept they are. |
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
I think Drew played really well, but you have to admit he was a grade a dumbass at times. Like the week he took out Holly. Perfect example of how he swayed to
whoever talked to him last.
|
|||
kmill |
|||
|
Wow, kinda surprised I'm not in the minority. I never thought he was a bad winner. Obviously not the sharpest, but did well enough to merit a win in my
book.
|
|||
Quiddity |
|||
GnarlsInCharge wrote: Well, what we do know is that Diane won the next HOH, put up Jase & Scott with Marvin replacing Jase, and Scott left 4-3 when it could have been 4-3 Marvin had Holly not been booted the prior week. I can't in any circumstance see Diane putting up Drew after she had won HOH considering how obsessed with him she was. In the end he won the game, so it didn't really matter. Can't overlook it though from a strategic standpoint :P |
|||
ModernDayClyde |
|||
|
I liked Drew when he was on his season. I wish that he would have stuck to his original alliance though. Seeing the four horsemen get to the end of the game
would have made the end of the season a little better.
If he hadn't won that HOH challenge I wonder how the game would have gone? |
|||
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor |
|||
|
Holly would've saved Scott's ass and have given the Horsemen a five strong alliance in the house. Keep in mind that some future HOH wins were
definitely out on the playing field since Marvin won a few afterwards after narrowly escaping victory. Now, if Diane had honestly put up Scott & Marvin
with Holly still in the house, well, that would be one of the most misguided HOH weeks in history. Truthfully, Jase might've made a bigger deal than it was
about Holly's vote being the savior or whatever. But we have to remember that Holly staying means the Twin Beasts
are kaput leaving Nakomis, Diane, Will & Karen left after Marvin leaves. Nakomis & Diane would be wise to not upset the majority, so they'd try to
sneak in thanks to their ties with Cowboy & Drew respectively, leaving Karen & Will out in the dust and practically guranteeing that two of the five
Hoursemen wound up in the Finals.
|
|||
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor |
|||
|
19. Marvin Latimer, BB5 (Score 108.2)
I don't know exactly what to make of this selection. He played the merchant-for-hire role quite well and just sort of did his own thing, perhaps proving in the process that you need an alliance in modern BB as the days of Will, Lisa and Allison had long past thanks to sharply divided sides in pretty much every season thereafter. I don't know what exactly makes Marvin a top 20 member other than BB not having too many strategically outstanding contestants in the first place. That alone allows him to finish ahead of other solid, but not stellar players. For the record, Marvin is the third contestant in a row from BB5 and there's five overall on the list - the most of any season. If you check out the first post in this thread, you'll see that I've started posting hints as to the makeup of the rest of this list. Coming Up Reasonably Soon: - Another winner - The only Donato on our list. Sadly, I had to keep pretending they'd pop up sooner so people wouldn't tune out of this thread earlier. - A challenge whore - A phenomenal player that unknowingly was their season's F2 goat |
|||
kmill |
|||
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor wrote:The winner could be nearly winner except Boogie. I have no idea which Donato it will be, but I'll bank on Daniele making the list of the two. There's a challenge whore every season, but I'll guess James. The phenomenal player CANNOT be Ivette |
|||
ribald2008 |
|||
|
Drew was 1 of the best Big Brother players ever!
|
|||
Quiddity |
|||
|
I hope the goat isn't my beloved...
|
|||
LKMOSCAR |
|||
A phenomenal player that unknowingly was their season's F2 goat Danielle? |
|||
CirieFieldsofDreams |
|||
|
I was going to say Danielle too but I thought she would have been at least Top 5. Not on the "coming-up soon list."
|
|||
ModernDayClyde |
|||
|
Danielle was certainly a phenomenal player but I'm not sure that she should show up this early on the list. Maybe it is someone else.
|
|||