All Seasons Popularity Poll -- DONE :) ty all, discuss results away

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
AlohaMars		#681	[-]
Posts: 73 (07/08/08 12:45 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CHINA Chicken - 1 Ashley - 5 Leslie - 6 Dave - 1 Aaron - 5 Sherea - 4 Jaime - 5 Jean-Robert - 0 Frosti - 8 James - 7 Erik - 5 Peih-Gee - 7 Denise - 0 Amanda - 7 Courtney - 10 Todd - 10 MICRONESIA ~ FANS vs. FAVOURITES Jon - 5 Mary - 2 Yau-Man - 4 Mikey B. - 4 Joel - 0 Jonathan - 10 Chet - 0 Kathy - 7 Tracy - 10 Ami - 7 Eliza - 8 Ozzy - 6 Jason - 4 James - 6 Alexis - 0 Erik - 9 Natalie - 7 Cirie - 9 Amanda - 7 Parvati - 4
kishuu		#682	[-]
Posts: 119 (07/08/08 1:20 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Thailandsurvivor wrote: The one thing I don't understand is how people are rating Amanda higher in Micronesia than in China. In China, everyone was rooting for her (or at least a wide majority) until her final tc performance. That shouldn't bring her down so much when she was actually playing the game the entire time and threw out some great quotes. In Micronesia though, only Ozztards should be rating her high as she was all talk (and doe eyes) and no game. I guess you can count the idol episode even though I thought that was the worst of the season, but she should in no shape or form be getting 2's in China then 8's in Micronesia from anyone. Kathy and Chet I can understand. Kathy had confessionals, was funny, and had a good edit. Chet had 0 confessionals until the swap, and looked like a piece of shit to me. Amanda was more boring in China to be honest. She kind of fades away because Courtney and Todd were there. She seemed to have more fun in Micro but... meh, she's very cliquey. When Ozzy found the idol, she goes like 'oh, I hope it stays within our four clique and our four clique only'. I liked her all the way till the finale in both seasons where she screwed up so bad. She tried to play a very Jenna M game honestly, but I think she's boring.
Thailandsurvivor		#683	[-]
Posts: 990 (07/08/08 1:30 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	kishuu wrote: Thailandsurvivor wrote: The one thing I don't understand is how people are rating Amanda higher in Micronesia than in China. In China, everyone was rooting for her (or at least a wide majority) until her final tc performance. That shouldn't bring her down so much when she was actually playing the game the entire time and threw out some great quotes. In Micronesia though, only Ozztards should be rating her high as she was all talk (and doe eyes) and no game. I guess you can count the idol episode even though I thought that was the worst of the season, but she should in no shape or form be getting 2's in China then 8's in Micronesia from anyone. Kathy and Chet I can understand. Kathy had confessionals, was funny, and had a good edit. Chet had 0 confessionals until the swap, and looked like a piece of shit to me. Amanda was more boring in China to be honest. She kind of fades away because Courtney and Todd were there. She seemed to have more fun in Micro but... meh, she's very cliquey. When Ozzy found the idol, she goes like 'oh, I hope it stays within our four clique and our four clique only'. I liked her all the way till the finale in both seasons where she screwed up so bad. She tried to play a very Jenna M game honestly, but I think she's boring. You don't have to like her at all. I'm just saying that it doesn't make sense for people to like her in MIcronesia yet not in China.
9RedWing19		#684	[-]
Posts: 2188 (07/08/08 9:21 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Courtney - 58...which I assume will be rounded down to 10 Beatles, you're definitely one of the more intelligent Sucks posters, but I hope your love of the Kelly G / Courtney types doesn't extend to real life. You know, be careful what you wish for, lest you might actually get it.
panurge46		#685	[-]
Posts: 1074 (07/08/08 10:46 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CHINA Chicken - 2: Ashley - 4: She had funny moments Leslie - 1: Stupid player Dave - 4: Another funny character Aaron - 5: Didn't think ahead Sherea - 2: Lazy Jaime - 6: She had game Jean-Robert - 4: Stupid but funny Frosti - 6: He brought energy James - 6: I really liked the big guy but still... Erik - 4: Lucky bastard, having both Jaime and Amanda liking him. Peih-Gee - 7: She was a fighter but not enough of a planner Denise - 3: She had a nice visit in China Amanda - 8: Strong game and great to look at. (At least what wasn't blurred!) Courtney - 7: Hilarious. She had no game but was smart enough to see who had game. Todd - 10: He played a great game. Each episode was edited as if he was following the Art of War. MICRONESIA ~ FANS vs. FAVOURITES Jon - 4: That's a lot for him Mary - 2: She had a nice fake pair Yau-Man - 3: He needed Earl Mikey B. - 5: One of the few fans to think AND act. Joel - 2: He acted without thinking. Jonathan - 10: Loved his determination and love of the game. Chet - 0: Dishrag face did nothing Kathy - 4: At least she had funny comments. Tracy - 6: Played too hard too fast but at least she played. Ami - 5: I liked the more decisive Vanuatu Ami more. Eliza - 6: She fought and gave one of the best moments ever. Ozzy - 5: He was a good tool to have around. Jason - 2: Everyone hated Jason. James - 7: Still liked him Alexis - 5: So much potential wasted. Erik - 4: Dumbass Natalie - 5: She played half a game, she gets half a score. Cirie - 10: One of the best manipulators ever. Amanda - 8: Played another strong game Parvati - 9: Her plan to play the game in stages worked perfectly. It was the season of the witch and it was a lot of fun to see her stirring the pot. PS: Did I forget to vote for CI and Fiji? Some will say I'm racist!!
SurvivorFan1989		#686	[-]
Posts: 14 (07/08/08 11:10 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CHINA Chicken - 3 Ashley - 6 Leslie - 10 Dave - 4 Aaron - 5 Sherea - 6 Jaime - 8 Jean-Robert - 1 Frosti - 7 James - 4 Erik - 8 Peih-Gee - 7 Denise - 6 Amanda - 8 Courtney - 6 Todd - 6 MICRONESIA ~ FANS vs. FAVOURITES Jon - 1 Mary - 4 Yau-Man - 7 Mikey B. - 5 Joel - 5 Jonathan - 8 Chet - 3 Kathy - 7 Tracy - 8 Ami - 8 Eliza - 10 Ozzy - 4 Jason - 7 James - 4 Alexis - 5 Erik - 7 Natalie - 4 Cirie - 7 Amanda - 8 Parvati - 6
ZeWish		#687	[-]
Posts: 243 (07/08/08 12:48 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CHINA Chicken - 4 Ashley - 9 Leslie - 10 Dave - 3 Aaron - 1 Sherea - 9 Jaime - 8 Jean-Robert - 7 Frosti - 6 James - 5 Erik - 6 Peih-Gee - 8 Denise - 1 Amanda - 5 Courtney - 10 Todd - 10 MICRONESIA ~ FANS vs. FAVOURITES Jon - 6 Mary - 1 Yau-Man - 4 Mikey B. - 6 Joel - 1 Jonathan - 8 Chet - 2 Kathy - 10 Tracy - 10 Ami - 9 Eliza - 10 Ozzy - 4 Jason - 5 James - 5 Alexis - 3 Erik - 7 Natalie - 8 Cirie - 9 Amanda - 8 Parvati - 6
Brazil Luvs Ami		#688	[-]
Posts: 63 (07/08/08 2:28 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CHINA Chicken - 0 Ashley - 0 Leslie - 7 Dave - 4 Aaron - 0 Sherea - 8 Jaime - 9 Jean-Robert - 6 Frosti - 0 James - 0 Erik - 0 Peih-Gee - 10 Denise - 0 Amanda - 2 Courtney - 9 Todd - 0 MICRONESIA ~ FANS vs. FAVOURITES Jon - 0 Mary - 0 Yau-Man - 3 Mikey B. - 5 Joel - 6 Jonathan - 8 Chet - 0 Kathy - 10 Tracy - 10 Ami - 10 Eliza - 6 Ozzy - 0 Jason - 0 James - 0 Alexis - 0 Erik - 0 Natalie - 5 Cirie - 9 Amanda - 0 Parvati - 7
Annoying Tool Fanboy		#689	[-]
Posts: 1848 (07/08/08 3:33 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CHINA Chicken - 1 Ashley - 4 Leslie - 0 Dave - 7 Aaron - 3 Sherea - 0 Jaime - 5 Jean-Robert - 7 Frosti - 3 James - 6 Erik - 5 Peih-Gee - 6 Denise - 0 Amanda - 4 Courtney - 10 Todd - 6 MICRONESIA ~ FANS vs. FAVOURITES Jon - 4 Mary - 2 Yau-Man - 4 Mikey B. - 4 Joel - 2 Jonathan - 7 Chet - 3 Kathy - 5 Tracy - 2 Ami - 7 Eliza - 8 Ozzy - 2 Jason - 5 James - 6 Alexis - 2 Erik - 4 Natalie - 4 Cirie - 6 Amanda - 5 Parvati - 5
beatles20147		#690	[-]
Posts: 11640 (07/08/08 11:54 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	In China, everyone was rooting for her (or at least a wide majority) until her final tc performance. That shouldn't bring her down so much when she was actually playing the game the entire time and threw out some great quotes. In Micronesia though, only Ozztards should be rating her high as she was all talk (and doe eyes) and no game. I guess you can count the idol episode even though I thought that was the worst of the season, but she should in no shape or form be getting 2's in China then 8's in Micronesia from anyone. Personally, I couldn't stand her in China because I just didn't get the hype at all--of course, it was because of the spoiler but other than a few standout moments ("My mom is going to kill me!", "I'm ready to make the whole frickin' pie") she was a nonentity for the most part. To be honest, up until the idol episode, I felt the same way in Micronesia. But I really liked her after that (although yeah, the finale meltdown was a bit much). So it's not so much Amanda that caused the low rating in China--I'd probably be more or less indifferent there if it weren't for everyone reading the spoiler and hyping her up as so extraordinary. Beatles, you're definitely one of the more intelligent Sucks posters, but I hope your love of the Kelly G / Courtney types doesn't extend to real life. You know, be careful what you wish for, lest you might actually get it. Heheh, don't worry, I go more for the girl next door types in real life (and incidentally, brunettes). But when it comes to the show, it doesn't get much more entertaining than hot, snarky blonde girls.
dontkilloffcharlie		#691	[-]
Posts: 314 (07/09/08 1:46 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CHINA Chicken - 0 Ashley - 5 Leslie - 5 Dave - 8 Aaron - 5 Sherea - 5 Jaime - 7 Jean-Robert - 3 Frosti - 3 James - 6 Erik - 2 Peih-Gee - 10 Denise - 4 Amanda - 5 Courtney - 10 Todd - 10 MICRONESIA ~ FANS vs. FAVOURITES Jon - 0 Mary - 0 Yau-Man - 4 Mikey B. - 0 Joel - 0 Jonathan - 5 Chet - 2 Kathy - 4 Tracy - 7 Ami - 6 Eliza - 10 Ozzy - 0 Jason - 4 James - 5 Alexis - 5 Erik - 3 Natalie - 7 Cirie - 9 Amanda - 8 Parvati - 9
LKMOSCAR		#692	[-]
Posts: 2886 (07/09/08 1:55 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CHINA Chicken - 4 Ashley - 6 Leslie - 4 Dave - 1 Aaron - 0 Sherea - 7 Jaime - 5 Jean-Robert - 2 Frosti - 5 James - 4 Erik - 6 Peih-Gee - 9 Denise - 5 Amanda - 3 Courtney - 9 Todd - 7 MICRONESIA ~ FANS vs. FAVOURITES Jon - 1 Mary - 2 Yau-Man - 3 Mikey B. - 0 Joel - 0 Jonathan - 3 Chet - 2 Kathy - 8 Tracy - 7 Ami - 5 Eliza - 4 (I like her a lot, but she wasn't edited too well this time) Ozzy - 3 Jason - 2 James - 6 Alexis - 4 Erik - 7 Natalie - 6 Cirie - 10 Amanda - 5 Parvati - 7
Alffmix		#693	[-]
Posts: 6065 (07/09/08 2:12 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CHINA Chicken - 2 Ashley - 8 Leslie - 7 Dave - 9 Aaron - 0 Sherea - 3 Jaime - 5 Jean-Robert - 10 Frosti - 2 James - 4 Erik - 3 Peih-Gee - 8 Denise - 2 Amanda - 7 Courtney - 10 Todd - 10 MICRONESIA ~ FANS vs. FAVOURITES Jon - 10 Mary - 2 (bod...lol) Yau-Man - 2 Mikey B. - 10 Joel - 8 Jonathan - 10 Chet - 0 Kathy - 7 Tracy - 7 Ami - 7 Eliza - 8 Ozzy - 7 Jason - 9 James - 4 Alexis - 3 Erik - 6 Natalie - 10 Cirie - 10 Amanda - 8 Parvati - 9
Pulau Tiga		#694	[-]
Posts: 4267 (07/09/08 6:07 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	China Chicken - 6 Ashley - 5 Leslie - 2 Dave - 9 Aaron - 3 Sherea - 1 Jaime - 4 Jean-Robert - 7 Frosti - 4 James - 8 Erik - 5 Peih-Gee - 6 Denise - 2 Amanda - 6 Courtney - 8 Todd - 6 Micronesia Jonny Fairplay - 7 Mary - 4 Yau-Man - 5 Mikey B - 6 Joel - 6 Jonathan - 7 Chet - 3 Kathy - 6 Tracy - 8 Ami - 5 Eliza - 6 Ozzy - 1 Jason - 2 Alexis - 4 James - 5 Erik - 7 Natalie - 2 Cirie - 10 Amanda - 5 Parvati - 5
iluvbigbrothersofun.jenjohnsonfansite		#695	[-]
Posts: 1 (07/09/08 6:23 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Eliza was boring on Micronesia, yet you like that? She was more compelling on Vanuatu, yet she has a lower popularity rating on that season? Sometimes you boggle my mind.
craig		#696	[-]
Posts: 13421 (07/09/08 6:43 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Characters are often most compelling when they have rivals, but those who like their rivals (Twila) give them 0. The key to high ratings in a 1-10 poll is not being enemies with other characters that have a major fab base. Jenna is S6, Eliza in S9, and Cirie in S16 had their best season - but predictably they don't get the highest poll numbers.
iluvbigbrothersofun.jenjohnsonfansite		#697	[-]
Posts: 10 (07/09/08 7:37 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Characters are often most compelling when they have rivals, but those who like their rivals (Twila) give them 0. The key to high ratings in a 1-10 poll is not being enemies with other characters that have a major fab base. I disagree. Rupert and Jon were rivals, but I loved them both. It isn't as automatic as you think, and I also am not saying it has no effect. The bottom line is that Eliza was a forgettable character on Micronesia asides from her boot episode. She warrants a lower popularity rating than the one she has (at least when compared to the other players who are listed on the chart).
iluvbigbrothersofun.jenjohnsonfansite		#698	[-]
Posts: 11 (07/09/08 7:46 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	but those who like their rivals (Twila) give them 0. Rupert and Jon were rivals, but I would give them both a 10. The key to high ratings in a 1-10 poll is not being enemies with other characters that have a major fab base. The key is to be relevant on a season. Jenna is S6, Eliza in S9, and Cirie in S16 had their best season - but predictably they don't get the highest poll numbers. Cirie definitely didn't have her best season in S16, unless you mean lasting the longest. She was way more relevant on Survivor: Exile Island.
Kitty Pryde1		#699	[-]
Posts: 5025 (07/09/08 8:03 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CHINA Chicken - 4 Ashley - 4 Leslie - 9 Dave - 9 Aaron - 2 Sherea - 5 Jaime - 4 Jean-Robert - 5 Frosti - 7 James - 6 Erik - 2 Peih-Gee - 10 Denise - 0 Amanda - 5 Courtney - 10 Todd - 7 MICRONESIA ~ FANS vs. FAVOURITES Jon - 2 Mary - 3 Yau-Man - 5 Mikey B. - 5 Joel - 2 Jonathan - 10 Chet - 3 Kathy - 10 Tracy - 10 Ami - 6 Eliza - 10 Ozzy - 0 Jason - 4 James - 6 Alexis - 0 Erik - 6 Natalie - 5 Cirie - 10 Amanda - 0 Parvati - 7
DiversityFan		#700	[-]
Posts: 79 (07/09/08 8:05 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I felt like Eliza was not edited to her poetential, she was more of a abserver this season. This Micronesia was a very crowded season.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

All Seasons Popularity Poll -- DONE :) ty all, discuss results away

Quick Reply