Top Chef 4: Like yesterday's cranberry foam it's over.

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
Will		#1961	[-]
Posts: 29273 (06/16/08 7:39 PM) Not a Registered User anymore Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	What does her looks have to do with her ability to cook?
Drew B		#1962	[-]
Posts: 3284 (06/16/08 7:43 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Nothing. She's ugly AND her food was consistently lousy enough to land her in the bottom grouping nearly every week...
downtown somewhere in Texas		#1963	[-]
Posts: 578 (06/16/08 8:10 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Will wrote: What does her looks have to do with her ability to cook? the fact that it looks like the grease from her hair could come in handy in case the deep fat fryer was empty one day. and holy shit, imagine trying to return an undercooked dish in her restaurant.
PAPAYOKE		#1964	[-]
Posts: 19597 (06/16/08 10:25 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I wouldn't be too surprised if it was demonstrated that Lisa's perma-bitchface had a negative effect on her food (above and beyond her bad cooking).
pjadedd		#1965	[-]
Posts: 6681 (06/17/08 5:22 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	PAPAYOKE wrote: I wouldn't be too surprised if it was demonstrated that Lisa's perma-bitchface had a negative effect on her food (above and beyond her bad cooking). Remember what she said about food tasting good when you're happy. When was this bitch ever happy?
Blondzilla5150		#1966	[-]
Posts: 868 (06/17/08 5:48 AM) A Danger to Myself & Others Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	No matter what anyone says or thinks, Lisa DID make it to the final 3, she beat out everyone else to get there, her food had to be good enough to make it that far, and again, that is a fact. Barftonia didn't make it, and if her food was good enough, she would have. Oh and... Stefatnie is not much of a looker herself. She has a hell of an uglybitchpigface going on as well! ETA: She comes off quite greasy in most of these pics also. ET: resize a botched sized photo. Last Edited By: Blondzilla5150 06/17/08 7:11 AM. Edited 3 times.
CoconutPhone		#1967	[-]
Posts: 13715 (06/17/08 6:57 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	and yet Lisa looks worse in every one of those pics! thanks for helping prove how much more of a douche Lisa is over Steph.
Blondzilla5150		#1968	[-]
Posts: 869 (06/17/08 7:00 AM) A Danger to Myself & Others Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I dunno, CP... I think its closer to a tie between the two.
maxxfisher		#1969	[-]
Posts: 1840 (06/17/08 7:06 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I think it's more of a tie between Richard & Lisa for second with Steph taking the lead. Steph=woman. Richard & Lisa=2 dudes
PAPAYOKE		#1970	[-]
Posts: 19598 (06/17/08 7:10 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Lisa is definitely Richard's brother from another mother. I love though Lisa-love-come-lately. Lisa fandom up to the finale was all about her being a "spoiler" (i.e. her food sucked and she outlasted "better" chefs), and now that she lost (big surprise only to those on crack), her cooking must've been great to make the finale. It would be excellent if she stormed off the reunion set in shame like past BRAVO contestants.
Blondzilla5150		#1971	[-]
Posts: 871 (06/17/08 7:10 AM) A Danger to Myself & Others Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Even with that fugly skirt and tank top, I don't see an ounce of femininity in Stefatnie's face, I actually think Richard looks more female than her, and he has better hair!
ginaf20697		#1972	[-]
Posts: 31114 (06/17/08 7:36 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	PAPAYOKE wrote: Lisa is definitely Richard's brother from another mother. I thought that was Jennifer.
pjadedd		#1973	[-]
Posts: 6686 (06/17/08 8:12 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Blondzilla5150 wrote: No matter what anyone says or thinks, Lisa DID make it to the final 3, she beat out everyone else to get there, her food had to be good enough to make it that far, and again, that is a fact. Barftonia didn't make it, and if her food was good enough, she would have. Oh and... Stefatnie is not much of a looker herself. She has a hell of an uglybitchpigface going on as well! I look at it more as her food just wasn't the worst every week. She won one challenge . . . for bacon. Even though Dale only won one Elimination challenge and made the final 3 back in season 3, at least he won at least one quick fire and wasn't perpetually the second choice every week to go home.
NiceToAnimals		#1974	[-]
Posts: 10020 (06/17/08 8:24 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Blondzilla5150 wrote: I don't see an ounce of femininity in Stefatnie's face There's been way more than an ounce of femininity in Lisa's face, I'll wager.
Blondzilla5150		#1975	[-]
Posts: 879 (06/17/08 9:16 AM) A Danger to Myself & Others Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	pjadedd wrote: I look at it more as her food just wasn't the worst every week. She won one challenge . . . for bacon. Even though Dale only won one Elimination challenge and made the final 3 back in season 3, at least he won at least one quick fire and wasn't perpetually the second choice every week to go home. I can actually agree with that, her food wasn't the worst every week is what it boils down to. She made it to the end, I just give her props for that. I am not dissappointed that Lisa lost, to Stephanie. I am dissappointed that Richard lost period, and that Stephanie won. There's been way more than an ounce of femininity in Lisa's face, I'll wager.
chuckersil		#1976	[-]
Posts: 599 (06/17/08 9:50 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Will wrote: What does her looks have to do with her ability to cook? Because her face sours milk and turns wine into vinegar.
Drew B		#1977	[-]
Posts: 3285 (06/17/08 9:55 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Blondzilla5150 wrote: No matter what anyone says or thinks, Lisa DID make it to the final 3, she beat out everyone else to get there, her food had to be good enough to make it that far, and again, that is a fact. Barftonia didn't make it, and if her food was good enough, she would have. In theory, that may be true, but this is reality TV we are talking about. Much more than the quality of her food comes into play when they decide whom to eliminate. I would venture that her food was NOT good enough to make it and that she WAS, in fact, the worst chef on at least one or two eliminations, but they kept her because producers felt she brought more to the show than the chefs who were eliminated instead.
Blondzilla5150		#1978	[-]
Posts: 884 (06/17/08 10:05 AM) A Danger to Myself & Others Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I don't know though, you really think that Lisa brought more to the show than say Spike or Antonia did? I don't buy it. If it was based more on personalities and such, Stephanie wouldn't haven't made it that far. ((just because she is the most boring of the bunch, by far)) There were a ton more dramatic and bolder personalities that could have been kept over Lisa, Like Andrew or Dale.. They would have added a lot more to the show, by far. Last Edited By: Blondzilla5150 06/17/08 10:07 AM. Edited 1 times.
Carboys Desire		#1979	[-]
Posts: 2376 (06/17/08 10:23 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Yes but by keeping her week after week they made her story more interesting. It is not that hard to conjure up a "let's keep the ugly fat chick week after week even though she sucks then we'll sucker the audience into thinking she could win in the final episode. Yeah! It's brilliant!"
Drew B		#1980	[-]
Posts: 3288 (06/17/08 10:24 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	There were a ton more dramatic and bolder personalities that could have been kept over Lisa, Like Andrew or Dale.. They would have added a lot more to the show, by far. But what Dale added by being cut when he got cut was the "shocking elimination". That's an important element, too, in the reality TV formula. If Lisa had been eliminated, she wouldn't have provided that. Also, I think Dale was cut because he was the "executive chef" and he failed to manage Lisa. If she hadn't sucked so badly, he wouldn't have been punished for it. I don't think anybody denies that his food is better than hers...

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Top Chef 4: Like yesterday's cranberry foam it's over.

Quick Reply