| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Toddomination |
|||
|
You put Todd at #157? Fuck this
|
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Next 10... what the heck...
149. Brian Corridan (Survivor Guatemala) Brian had a lot of potential going into Guatemala, and he was doing pretty well until the random swap placed him, Gary, and Amy at a pretty bad disadvantage. Even worse considering old tribal lines dissolved after the separation, so even if Brian did make the merge, there was no place for him in NuNakum, and he was in a bad position at NuYaxha. Anyways, he was a good player who got screwed. Bate Blake was hilarious, and he had all the right ideas for Amy especially, and Gary, but neither went along with them. Reason he doesn't place higher is that I had other faves that season and he's been overshadowed.
148. Becky Lee (Survivor Cook Islands) Becky is a lot higher than she probably should be, but I think she got a raw deal, edit wise. Or maybe it served her right for not only being reserved in public, but also in confessionals. Whatever the case may be, she was very much a non-entity. The reason she makes it this high was A) her alliance with Yul and B) She was a better strategist than people give her credit for, and I really wish they'd have shown more of it. An example is how when Candice went to exile island the first time, in an insider video, she was most concerned about Becky. Why? Because she said Becky was the main person communicating between Candice, Yul and Jonathan -- shows she was a strategist. But ultimately she was boring on the show, which I know isn't the case in real life, but still.
147. Clay Jordan (Survivor Thailand) I hated Clay during Thailand's original airing. He was a cocky some on a bitch and he was downright obnoxious and annoying. But again, on rewatch, he's really a hilarious character, and I can totally appreciate him as a character. I hated the way he exploded on Jake etc, but aside from his social game, he really did play a good game, strategically at least. What he pulled with Penny was absolutely brilliant, and he doesn't get enough credit for that. He probably should be lower, but meh.
146. Ghandia Johnson (Survivor Thailand) At the time Thailand aired, I hated Ghandia so much. She'd probably be bottom 10 if my mindset was the same as it was then. But at least she had some redemption at the finale when she genuinely felt bad for the way the whole Ted thing went. But she handled that oddly, and it was uncomfortable, but slightly entertaining at the same time. I hated her because she conveniently left out the part where Ted apologized. But upon rewatch, this bitch was hilarious. She was so funny when she did impressions of Clay etc, I just couldn't stop laughing. She was batshit crazy and I loved watching her when I saw the season again last year.
145. Matthew Von Ertfelda (Survivor Amazon) I didn't care for Matt at first, since he was pretty UTR. I didn't think the tribe was purposefully isolating him either, that really made no sense to me, personally. Then at the swap, he became weird around Shawna, which I didn't like. He was a bumbling idiot most of the season, and I really didn't like him. Until final 7. That episode made me like the guy, and I was really rooting for the Christy-Matt-Butch trio. He quickly pissed me off by voting out Christy the next ep, but he showed his good natured side through the rest of the season, and he was very level-headed, which I liked. He ended up playing the person who taught him everything, which was a fun twist of fate. His final episode with his reflection about needing to have more fun in his life was nice. But I still think he was a bit weird, though I can appreciate him to put him this high.
I'd probably have Ryan top 60 at least, since I really liked him in PI. I was rooting for the Morgans during the original airing, and Ryno seemed like a
genuine guy. Smart, athletic, fun etc. But unfortunately, post show, he's been kind of pathetic, and that is why I have put him much lower.
Lydia would be a lot lower, but once her son passed away, I felt so bad for her, and I softened up to her. I rewatched the season after the news, and I realize how much spunk she had for the game. She fought her heart out, and I appreciate that. No one appreciated the experience more than Lydia did. It was cute to see her so excited about the Mayan people coming to teach them stuff at final 4. I <3 Lydia, but she still was pretty UTR and followed a lot, so I can't put her much higher than this.
Danni for the first 3/4 of the season at least was a bore, and I didn't care for her at all. But after that, she really stepped it up, and I noticed the game she played. Post show interviews revealed more of her strategy, and it was brilliant. Not many people can finagle their way out of a situation like she did. Sure, she was the weakest of the NuYaxha people, but she adapted to that... she knew she had more time to scramble than her tribemates did, which allowed her to find the cracks and blow them wide open. She really only had one card to play, Rafe, and she played him beautifully. For that, I put her this high, but I can't put her higher because she was boring.
141. Alicia Calaway (Survivor: The Australian Outback)
140. Shane Powers (Survivor Panama Exile Island) I have mixed feelings about Shane. Half of me loves his zaniness, because it provides a shit load of entertainment. His antics out there were pretty hilarious overall. From using the girls soap, to Courtney being a lunatic, to the way he lost it on Aras/Cirie at final 7 as part of his plan. I'd probably have him higher, because while I thought he was an asshole, I knew it was for show and it was entertaining. Plus his love for his some was nice to see. Then when he gets voted out, he's a complete douchetard. I mean, he's upset with Aras... the guy he was going to vote out at the very next TC??? He's mad at Cirie, when he was telling her she was out on day 6??? He was going to backstab people, but then got upset when he was backstabbed. which put a sour taste in my mouth. So it's why he ends up pretty much at the half way point of the entire list. |
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Last Edited By: chapera rocks
06/15/08 12:09 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
spnintendo |
|||
|
:iiam Who makes the top 100...
|
|||
AidanAcello |
|||
chapera rocks wrote:Nice write-up, Chapera Rocks <3. Yay for Vanuatu Top 10! |
|||
ribald2008 |
|||
|
Nice avatar Aidan!
|
|||
Fei Long Dragon |
|||
|
Becky hidden mastermind <3
|
|||
Edinboro |
|||
|
This os a great list. The only one I disagree with is Jenna M. I thought she was a lot better to get such a low placement, but her Post show should have
brought her up, but hey, there is still allstars.
|
|||
Oowatanite |
|||
|
144. Ryan Opray (Survivor Pearl Islands)
I'd probably have Ryan top 60 at least, since I really liked him in PI. I was rooting for the Morgans during the original airing, and Ryno seemed
like a genuine guy. Smart, athletic, fun etc. But unfortunately, post show, he's been kind of pathetic, and that is why I have put him much lower.
|
|||
Quiddity |
|||
|
All this bashing of Danni's game, particularly by Oowatanite (I must say, Oo, don't you just LLLLLLLLLOOOOOOOOOOVVVVVVVVVVEEEEEEEEEE how my Celtics totally embarressed your team Thursday night? And all the experts told me the Lakers were gonna win!) is ridiculous. The fact of the matter is, despite being totally screwed by the tribal switch, she played all her cards right, and rather than sit back after winning immunity like so many have done over the years, she completely took things to her advantage and got Judd voted out, then duped Rafe so much so that he booted Cindy and Lydia over her. Is she boring as hell? Hell yeah! But she played the game tremendously and is one of the game's best winners. |
|||
Romber Rulz |
|||
|
Danni is one of my all time faves and her game is vastly underrated. <3
|
|||
AidanAcello |
|||
ribald2008 wrote: Thanks!!!!!!!!!! :) |
|||
spnintendo |
|||
|
I think PI was one of the rare instances where I liked both tribes. Gawd I <3 that season.
|
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Next 10...
139. Earl Cole (Survivor Fiji) I'd originally thought I'd put Earl a lot lower, because on the show, I thought he was arrogant when he wasn't boring. He was shoved down our throats despite not being that interesting. But thinking back, he was a pretty nice guy. I think he's been one of the worst winners, strategically, simply because he didn't do all that much; he excelled at social, which is what took him that far and won him the game, but I thought his strategic game was weak and barely existent. Still he did something right and it was nice of him to give 1/2 the money to his Mom.
138. Terry Dietz (Survivor Panama Exile Island) I'm surprised Terry made it up this high, because he was an asshole. A big asshole. What did I hate about him? He was condescending as all hell, he was obnoxious, he had the "I'm better than you" attitude, he betrayed his best friend Dan, he blindsided Ruth Marie, and upon getting voted out and being fairly bitter about it, still claimed he never lied in the game, which he did. He was an asshole when things didn't go his way, like at the final 4 challenge. Then when he was so close minded to think that Moms weren't as important as significant others, and when he exploded on Cirie for putting her torch on the ground. But through all of that, he was still likable in a way. He was a great underdog, and I was rooting for him to do well for La Mina. So while he was a complete asshole, I still was rooting for him in a strange way.
137. Tammy Leitner (Survivor Marquesas) Tammy, the last of the Rotu 4. I liked Tammy initially, I thought she was a tough girl, fun to watch, competitive etc. But then the Rotu4 alliance came, and I didn't like that. But at least she wasn't a huge bitch like John was, and she didn't want to throw the challenge (even though it was dumb not to looking back). Even after the Rotu 4 was taken down, she had a pretty good attitude... she didn't give up and fought pretty hard to stay. I loved when she bitched about Zoe, cuz she was absolutely right. It made me <3 Tammy again. But at final tribal, she was a huge bitch, which was enough to knock her down several places. She was too bitter/hypocritical.
136. Heidi Strobel (Survivor Amazon) I thought Heidi was going to be a nice girl coming into Amazon, since she was a teacher after all, but boy was I wrong. In episode 3, she really showed what an OTTNN bitch she could be. Trashing the older women like she was better because she had a bunch of silicon in her chest. When she said in a confessional, that Christy was a hindrance or something and that "If you can't understand the people around you...", I wanted to bitchslap her. She's supposed to be compassionate... help her out and don't stick your nose up. I thought she might be a great girl after the first swap when she was stuck with two girls she didn't interact with + 2 old men, and she was very nice. She stuck up for Christy, and was going to refuse to vote for her. She actually made an effort, maybe because she didn't have anyone else, but still. She didn't like the way the boys would go off and not include her and Christy, who were supposed to be a part of the group. But when she merged, she got right back into the clique, which sucked. But once the clique broke up, she became okay since she at least talked to Christy, and didn't ignore her. Plus post show, she had a lot of nice things to say about her, and wished she got to know her better. Plus, she's this high also because she provided hilarious moments, such as a rock and a hard stone, and how she was such a huge threat and how the boys were so "scared" her her mastermindness and how every plan revolved around her.
135. Sylvia Kwan (Survivor Fiji) Sylvia was kind of overbearing in the first episode, and sometimes her voice was really grating. But overall, she was a refreshing character. It was kind of sad to see her go, especially with so many duds in the Fiji cast. But Sylvia was great for the first 3 eps, and I wish she would have lasted. The scene where she was trying to slip and slide to no avail was one of the funniest moments in the show.
134. Tina Scheer (Survivor Panama Exile Island) Tina was one of my faves going into the season because of the son she lost, and the story touched me.
133. Linda Spencer (Survivor Africa) I originally had Linda 50 spots lower, but she rose up high because I realize was a great character she was. She was zany, but caring at the same time. At the time of Africa, I hated her, along with Carl and Frank, but she really was a nice lady, and reading her bio on another website, she's very inspirational. Kinda wish I put her higher. But I still have to take into account the show, and I did root again the old people quite a bit, since they did start the drama. I was so happy to see Linda go at the time, but her scenes in ep 4 were hilarious, especially with the whole "THANK YOU!" and "Didn't yo mamma ever hug ya??".
132. Aaron Reisberger (Survivor China) A lot of people are probably WTF on him being so high, but I kind of liked him. He was a nice guy. He was the leader of FL, and was in a fairly good position within the tribe, alliance wise. He's also the person I think was the most robbed by a twist, since the whole swap was designed to screw over the stronger people, and that's exactly what happened to Aaron, but damn, it made for one hell of an episode. Probably the best of the season. I was blindsided, it was crazy. But he was a nice guy, I thought he'd go a lot further, but he should have lied to the ZH people more.
131. Tom Buchanan (Survivor Africa) I started out the season disliking Tom because he was an asshole to Clarence, even though I was no fan of Clarence either. But after that, he grew on me. He was pretty hilarious. The whole Jew thing was the funniest moment of Africa bar none. But the way he acted towards Kim J was kind of pathetic, and All Stars left a bad taste in my mouth, so he wasn't as enjoyable upon rewatch. Still a great character, and 131 isn't too bad.
130. Carl Bilancione (Survivor Africa) I hated Carl during the original airing. He started the alliance against the youngins, and he was an asshole about Lindsey getting sick. Not only that, he expected Silas to take 5th place in their little alliance. He also was a huge dick in that he claimed to know what Silas was up to when Silas was baiting him to talk about all his money, yet if he was so smart, then why did he continue to do it?? Made no sense. I was so nervous when he and Lindsey were going head to head and was sooooo relieved when he left and the youngins took control. But he was a great character, and a pretty cool guy looking back. |
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Survivor Borneo
01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. 09. 10. 11. 12. STACEY (#150) 13. SEAN (#162) 14. DIRK (#167) 15. B.B. (#246) 16. SUSAN (#269) Survivor: The Australian Outback 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. 09. 10. ALICIA (#141) 11. MICHAEL (#160) 12. KEL (#164) 13. MITCHELL (#165) 14. DEBB (#232) 15. TINA (#266) 16. JEFF (#270) Survivor Africa 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. 09. 10. CARL (#130) 11. TOM (#131) 12. LINDA (#133) 13. DIANE (#161) 14. BRANDON (#194) 15. KIM J. (#247) 16. LEX (#276) Survivor Marquesas 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. 09. 10. TAMMY (#137) 11. PATRICIA (#158) 12. PETER (#159) 13. VECEPIA (#166) 14. ROBERT (#234) 15. ZOE (#260) 16. JOHN (#265) Survivor Thailand 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. GHANDIA (#146) 09. CLAY (#147) 10. JED (#184) 11. ROBB (#185) 12. JAN (#191) 13. TED (#195) 14. STEPHANIE (#216) 15. ERIN (#217) 16. JOHN (#220) Survivor Amazon 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. HEIDI (#136) 08. MATTHEW (#145) 09. JEANNE (#206) 10. ROB (#211) 11. RYAN (#225) 12. DANIEL (#226) 13. JOANNA (#248) 14. ROGER (#250) 15. JENNA (#254) 16. ALEX (#258) Survivor Pearl Islands 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. RYAN O. (#144) 09. LILLIAN (#156) 10. OSTEN (#178) 11. SHAWN (#212) 12. MICHELLE (#213) 13. RYAN S. (#233) 14. RUPERT (#242) 15. BURTON (#267) 16. JON (#272) Survivor All*Stars 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. 09. KATHY (#176) 10. RUPERT (#177) 11. COLBY (#179) 12. ROB C. (#228) 13. TINA (#231) 14. TOM (#249) 15. JENNA L. (#256) 16. SUSAN (#257) 17. ALICIA (#273) 18. LEX (#277) Survivor Vanuatu 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. 09. 10. BRADY (#151) 11. BROOK (#153) 12. CHAD (#155) 13. TRAVIS (#163) 14. TWILA (#182) 15. JOHN P. (#196) 16. JOHN K. (#224) 17. LISA (#244) 18. SCOUT (#264) Survivor Palau 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. 09. 10. KATIE (#152) 11. WILLARD (#169) 12. JOLANDA (#174) 13. TOM (#190) 14. JONATHAN (#202) 15. JEFF (#203) 16. IBREHEM (#204) 17. CARYN (#205) 18. JANU (#227) 19. ASHLEE (#239) 20. JAMES (#240) Survivor Guatemala 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. DANNI (#142) 07. LYDIA (#143) 08. BRIAN (#149) 09. JAMIE (#171) 10. BRIANNA (#188) 11. RAFE (#189) 12. JIM (#192) 13. JUDD (#199) 14. BOBBY JON (#209) 15. BLAKE (#210) 16. MORGAN (#214) 17. MARGARET (#215) 18. BROOKE (#223) Survivor Panama Exile Island 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. TINA (#134) 09. TERRY (#138) 10. SHANE (#140) 11. NICK (#154) 12. DANIELLE (#168) 13. COURTNEY (#219) 14. BRUCE (#221) 15. MELINDA (#235) 16. ARAS (#236) Survivor Cook Islands 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. BECKY (#148) 09. ADAM (#181) 10. CECILIA (#187) 11. SUNDRA (#193) 12. SEKOU (#198) 13. BRAD (#230) 14. REBECCA (#238) 15. NATE (#245) 16. JENNY (#251) 17. JESSICA (#252) 18. BILLY (#255) 19. J.P. (#261) 20. OZZY (#271) Survivor Fiji 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. SYLVIA (#135) 07. EARL (#139) 08. EDGARDO (#170) 09. GARY (#172) 10. JESSICA (#197) 11. ANTHONY (#200) 12. CASSANDRA (#207) 13. BOO (#208) 14. MICHELLE (#218) 15. LILIANA (#229) 16. MOOKIE (#237) 17. RITA (#253) 18. DREAMZ (#259) 19. ROCKY (#274) Survivor China 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. 09. 10. 11. AARON (#132) 12. TODD (#157) 13. JAMES (#175) 14. JEAN-ROBERT (#201) 15. CHICKEN (#222) 16. DENISE (#263) Survivor Micronesia: Fans vs. Favourites 01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. 09. 10. 11. 12. NATALIE (#173) 13. JAMES (#180) 14. ALEXIS (#183) 15. MIKEY B. (#186) 16. MARY (#241) 17. CHET (#243) 18. JON (#262) 19. JOEL (#268) 20. OZZY (#275) |
|||
spnintendo |
|||
|
Aaron was sooooo robbed. It was the only time I almost didn't like PGoddess.
|
|||
hippo2002 |
|||
|
Kel Gleason is such a nice guy! Kel<3
|
|||
chad6 |
|||
|
I thought Aaron was robbed too, and I liked him. Why do people hate him again?
|
|||
0 hail mary 0 |
|||
|
Linda and Carl making it so high makes me puke but I guess they brought some entertainment
|
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Last batch before tomorrow evening...
129. Wanda Shirk (Survivor Palau) I didn't really care for Wanda pre-show, and even on the show, she was somewhat likable, but also somewhat annoying. But post-show, I think she was sweet. She had a lot of spunk for the game, and it's too bad she was screwed like that. She had so much heart for the game, and still does so much blogging, or at least I think she still does. Definitely was robbed and I still think they should bring her back and give her a fair shake at things.
128. Ashley Massaro (Survivor China) I thought I'd hate Ashley when it was spoiler that she was on the show. But after watching her pre-show video, she seemed like a sweet girl. On the show, she was pretty fun to watch. She was sweet, but had spunk. She did unfortunately get sick, which probably cost her the game.. I really think Dave would have gone had Ashley not been sick, especially with the ties she had to Jaime. But yeah, the sickness curse for the second boot hits again (and they're always female -- Jessie, Tanya, Janet, and Ashley). Can't put her higher because I liked everyone else more. This is where I lot of the likable early boots are coming up.
127. Dave Johnson (Survivor Amazon) I liked Dave through most of Amazon, but never really loved him. He was a pretty good guy. The only thing that bugged me was how dumb he was in certain situations, cuz he was thinking with the wrong head. I mean, he steals Heidi, someone who was clearly a power player on the original Jaburu, and then keeps her? Doesn't even approach the outsider, Jeanne? Just seemed weird. And Dumb. Post merge, I was rooting against his alliance, but after Roger left, I was hoping he'd find some way to stay in the game. It was also nice how he taught Christy dancing, or was taught by her, not sure, but it was nice. Even if it was only when he needed her. Speaking of which, how the hell do people know that Dave, erm, "relieved" himself on that bathtub reward on Amazon? It seemed like it spread over the boards like wild fire, yet how do people even know this??
126. Tijuana Bradley (Survivor Pearl Islands) I hated T in the premiere, because she was a raving bitch at the market. After that, she slowly grew on me, and eventually I liked her again. I was always rooting for the Morgans, and so I was happy to see them kick ass and win 3 back to back immunities, only to get screwed by the outcast twist. :/ But then at final TC, she seemed to kind of have something against Sandra. Overall, she places lower than other people who made it far because I wasn't that into her, I just liked her.
125. Stacy Kimball (Survivor Fiji) Stacey places lower because she didn't get the airtime. She's one of the post-ASS contestants that I think had real potential to be a complex character if they had only shown her. She had the complete story arc. Villainous bitch who was so cutthroat, she didn't even treat the people outside of her alliance with respect. The whole coffee scene was pretty terrible. Then when she got slammed in the challenge where you tell people how you really feel, she didn't act all better than everyone and be pissed about what she heard (cough Alicia cough). She realized something she did was making people dislike her, and she turned a new leaf and decided to change it. And in the end, some of the people she treated like dogshit ended up saying she was one of their closest friends (Dreamz + Cassandra). She still was bad at the game though. I don't know what her strategy was post merge besides to ride Cassandra's coattails.
124. Frosti Zernow (Survivor China) I liked Frosti, since he seemed like a genuine kid with a lot of spunk. He always tried his best at challenges, and when he was switched over, he made the best of his situation. He should have crawled up FL's ass like he did, except he should have had an escape route for post-merge, instead of kicking the ladder and stranding himself at their mercy. Which is why he places here. While he had spunk and was funny, he was also a dumbass for sticking with FL. Why oh why would he? He was better friends with ZH. He would have gone farther with ZH. Grab JR and run like hell, I don't see what he was thinking.
123. Sherea Lloyd (Survivor China) I thought Sherea was going to be the sweetheart of the season, considering she's a teacher for 4th graders and she looked like the second coming of Cirie (Cassandra was not at all), but that turned out to be false. Not because she was boring, but because she was a pretty crappy player that was hilarious as all hell. Bitch was whacked, and if she had any problem with you, you'd get an earful. The scene at TC where Ashley left, was so funny. "DID YA NOT HEAR WHAT COME OUTTA MY MOUTH??". Then the whole "BACK UP OFF ME!" scene was the shit, though she was wrong in that situation. The way she called out JR at TC was pretty funny as well. She also had one of my fave voting confessionals, "You are the weakest link, goodbye".
122. Dave Cruser (Survivor China) I thought Dave was such a zany character. That's probably the word that describes him best. He was crazy! In the short time he was on the show, he provided a lot of entertainment. In ep 1, I thought he might go very far because he seemed like a good player. But then in ep 2, he emerged as a crazy as workaholic that was scary to watch sometimes.
121. Nicole Delma (Survivor Pearl Islands) Nicole was such a great character for a first boot. She wasn't the typical pretty girl you'd expect from her, but she actually was sassy and had a lot of ideas in her head. She didn't decide to just join the clique alliance (That I admittedly liked better btw), but instead she decided that people like Ryan S and Lill deserved to stay, and tried to help them out by voting out the person she felt shouldn't stay. She went out on a limb, and could have grabbed Darrah and made it happen. But stupid Lill opened her mouth for God knows why, and screwed it up. GJ Lill, cuz you and your buddy went home after her within 6 days. But Nicole was amazing. Too bad she couldn't have made it further, she'd probably have made it higher on this list as well.
120. Darrah Johnson (Survivor Pearl Islands) Darrah was my fave throughout PI, and I loved watching her kickass at pretty much every challenge, and was part of the Morgan 5, who I liked. She unfortunately though, was kind of boring, which puts her this low. After I realized it, she was no longer my fave, but she'll always hold a special place with me because I was rooting for her a lot during PI, and I thought she kicked a lot of ass, especially in those challenges where she won back-to-back-to-back immunities. Amazing!
Last Edited By: chapera rocks
06/17/08 9:09 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||