| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Lobsters |
|||
|
|
|||
memeonly |
|||
ProbstFan123 wrote: PF, I'll take this for now and live in a fantasy world if it's not true! |
|||
ProbstFan123 |
|||
|
Remember, this is the site that predicted no one would be eliminated during Idol Gives Back week. :)
But even a stopped watch is right twice a day. They have a 50/50 chance of being right this time. |
|||
swim4life227 |
|||
lei wrote: If they wanted him to win, I think they would have given him the proper praise. He probably has the fanbase to win no matter where the judges fall, so what the hell is the point of giving Archuleta all the praise for Cook to win. If the reverse would have occurred with Cook taking the night over Archuleta there would have been zero possibility of the Archtards rising above. Cook still could win though. I still don't buy the whole, "They don't care and whatever the fans decide they will go with." If that was the truth, then why not do what Aussie Idol does and not have the judges chyme in and just let the viewers decide. The reason they don't is because they need the judges there to manipulate the outcome. |
|||
Sux at life |
|||
swim4life227 wrote: As Lei said, the media is just regurgitating the crap of the judges. Heck, just watching it from home, I was left with the same feeling
|
|||
Lost Survivor Heroes |
|||
|
I thought I'd be over the Archie pimping from last night, but it's renewed again! I hope I have the satisfaction of thinking of the mouths dropping if
(when) Cook's announced as the Idol!
|
|||
Paris Hilton |
|||
|
Unfortuantely for us Archie fans, I believe Archie will get runner-up tonight.
It's a huge let down. I almost wish he had sucked it up last night and the judges cut him down. Because that would have been easier to swallow. But if Archie loses, despite all the praise he got, it will be a big let down. Oh well. I am really happy for him either way. Both contestants will have a great future. |
|||
Velveeta Revolver |
|||
Hopefully Archie wins so I can witness the meltdown first hand. Yes and just think, you'll finally be able to change your avatar unlike us tardlings who jumped the gun by showing support for our favorite before they had won . . . I can't take a lot of stock in what Zabasearch says although I'd love to. Aren't they the stunted cunts that change their "results" once the official ones are revealed? Someone screencap that mofo. I do take stock however in my demented granny coworker that thought that Cooktard's song choices were "icky" and actually likes Archtard's version of Imagine better than the original. |
|||
Relynn |
|||
Velveeta Revolver wrote: Well, I haven't gotten wind of her review for this week, BUT my 81 year old Grandmother as of before the finale, was rooting for Cook.. She said that she thought that David A had a lovely voice but no experience or versatility. My mom (58) and or family friend in 70's, all think Cook should win too... |
|||
lei |
|||
Paris Hilton wrote: (Assuming our hunches and the predictions are correct) I would feel the same way if it were reversed. While I'm no Archie fan, the way (I believe) the
AI machine orchestrated this "shocker" sets the fetus up for a nasty fall. That and his dad to deal with, ugh. I can't stand Archie's
singing but, assuming he loses, somewhere in my overwhelming elation about Cook, I will feel bad for the kid.
I agree both will have great futures.
|
|||
Tigershere |
|||
|
Any chance Simons praise was a reverse psy deal on voters ?
I am not sure he likes the kid |
|||
lei |
|||
Tigershere wrote: Call me crazy but I'm now convinced it was. Mobilized Cooktards.
|
|||
Paris Hilton |
|||
|
I honestly believe the results would have been the same no matter what the judges said.
Cook has had a very decent lead the past few weeks. His fans were going to vote no matter what. |
|||
Jenny du Jour |
|||
|
I would be in t.ears but honestly I only wanted archuleta to win because I thought he was a trainwreck. If next season is as boring as this one was, I am done
with this show.
|
|||
ProbstFan123 |
|||
|
I don't think I can go through another season of this. Too much of an emotional roller-coaster.
And unless they make some serious format changes, I probably won't tune in anyway. The only reason I'm watching this season is because of the two Davids. I will buy both of their albums, and any albums they put out in the future. But honestly I'm pretty much over AI at this point. Unless they really do get "the best top 24 ever" next season, I'll probably skip it. |
|||
BarbH918 |
|||
|
Funny, this is the least emotionally involved I've ever been in the finale. While I want Cook to win, it doesn't really matter because he's going
to do some great music. In fact, if he doesn't win, he won't have to sell out to the Idol machine.
I think David A will be very unsuccessful unless he's marketed correctly - he's perfect for High School Musical or something like that, but he'll make boring MTV videos. I tried voting for 3 hours last night (Pittsburgh) and never once got through for David Cook. I was so excited the first time it rang through only to hear that "all circuits are busy now..." |
|||
Jenny du Jour |
|||
|
I tried voting a couple of times for archuleta last night but I just got the message that said my call couldn't get through so try again. I called some of
my friends and they couldn't get through either, must have been a local thing I guess.
|
|||
NataSatan666 |
|||
swim4life227 wrote: No, hopefully you die in your sleep and save everyone on the board your fantard filled posts |
|||
The Infamous bLuEeYeDsOuL |
|||
NataSatan666 wrote: too painless. ;)
|
|||
Lovejonze |
|||
ProbstFan123 wrote:
|
|||