1. Pearl Islands
2. Marquesas
3. Amazon
4. Micronesia
5. Borneo
6. Exile Island
7. China
8. Africa
9. Fiji
10. Australia
11. Palau
12. Vanuatu
13. All-Stars
14. Guatemala
15. Thailand
16. Cook Islands
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Pulau Tiga |
|||
|
Obviously Micronesia is going to get a huge boost due to its recent completion.
1. Pearl Islands 2. Marquesas 3. Amazon 4. Micronesia 5. Borneo 6. Exile Island 7. China 8. Africa 9. Fiji 10. Australia 11. Palau 12. Vanuatu 13. All-Stars 14. Guatemala 15. Thailand 16. Cook Islands |
|||
panurge46 |
|||
|
It's always the story that counts:
1- Panama: Exile Island - The "Lord of the Idol" lost! 2- Guatamala: "The Fall of the Mayan Empire" and its Last Queen Steph. 3- Borneo: "Survivor" 4- The Australian Outback: "Good People can Win" 5- China: "The Art of War" 6- Micronesia: "Survivor Fans are Dumb!" 7- The Amazon: "Beautiful Women Rule the Amazon". 8- Vanuatu: "The Revenge of Chief Roy Matta" 9-Pearl Islands: "Pirates Steal, Pillage... and Come Back to Life" 10- Marquesas: "Pride before the Fall" 11- Palau: "Making the Right Decisions" 12- The Cook Islands: "Let's Represent" 13- Fiji: "How Can Earl Possibly Win?" 14- Africa: "How Not to Play" 15- All-Star: "You Always Make the Same Mistakes." 16- Thailand: "Mean, Ugly People." |
|||
Lamb Chop is Hot |
|||
|
1. Borneo
2. Pearl Islands 3. China 4. Exile Island 5. Micronesia- Boring pre-merge, but the post-merge made up for it 6. Amazon 7. Guatemala 8. Palau- Used to be in my top 5 but after watching it again I didn't like it as much 9. Vanuatu 10. Marquesas 11. Australian Outback- Same as Palau 12. Africa 13. Cook Islands 14. Fiji 15. Thailand 16. All-Stars |
|||
Edinboro |
|||
|
why does everyone hate thailand??
|
|||
RavuRules |
|||
|
Actually, Thailand's status has improved quite a bit given that it used to be considered the virtually unanimous "worst" around here. It seems
people have now turned their hate to the race seasons especially Fiji which got taken down several pegs, despite being a lot more popular after its initial
airing. Around the time of the controversial debates and Probst's public criticism of the season, then it became alright to bash it and its stock
plummeted dramatically here
|
|||
CSCin3D |
|||
|
|
|||
RavuRules |
|||
|
A simple glance at the 1st few pages of this thread say otherwise
|
|||
XtremeInnovator420 |
|||
|
Well, I've certainly always regarded it as a season that was so bad it even had a "we as the editors, don't even give a fuck about this season" feel to it. |
|||
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
|
1- Marquesas
2- Vanuatu 3- China 4- Borneo 5- Pearl Islands 6- Micronesia (After adjusting to the winner, it was pretty good) 7- Exile Island 8- Africa 9- Guatemala 10- Amazon 11- Australia 12- Fiji 13- Thailand 14- Palau 15- All-Stars 16- Cook Islands |
|||
chad6 |
|||
|
I'll add up the current results soon
|
|||
craig |
|||
|
1. Amazon
2 Micronesia 3 Pearl Islands 4 Borneo 5 Marquesas 6 Cook Islands 7 Vanuatu 8 All-Stars 9 Guatemala 10 Panama 11 Outback 12 Palau 13 China 14 Africa 15 Fiji 16 Thailand I like seasons with powershifts, good female charaacters, and something unique and controversial to talk about. |
|||
SenseiKreese |
|||
|
Here are my personal updated rankings.
THE ELITES 1. Pearl Islands 2. Marquesas 3. Amazon 4. Vanuatu 5. Micronesia THE GOODS 6. Africa 7. Australia 8. China 9. Palau 10. Fiji 11. Thailand THE ONE THAT DOESN'T HOLD UP WELL 12. Borneo THE SEASONS THAT WERE OKAY, BUT I HAD A GENERAL PROBLEM WITH 13. Cook Islands 14. All-Stars THE SEASONS THAT BORED ME 15. Guatemala 16. Exile Island |
|||
spnintendo |
|||
|
1. PI
2. Amazon 3. Borneo 4. Australia 5. Micronesia 6. Marquesas 7. China 8. EI 9. Palau 10. Guatemala 11. CI 12. Africa 13. ASS 14. Vanuatu 15. Thailand 16. Fiji Probably ranked it too high. |
|||
Edinboro |
|||
|
damn!! at all you pearl islands lovers.
|
|||
Bobby Jon goes apeshit |
|||
|
Your opinion on seasons of Survivor suck Edinboro. Just sayin.
Surprised that you ranked Guatemala so low SK. Based on the funny 115, I always thought you quite enjoyed the season. |
|||
SenseiKreese |
|||
|
As a season, I thought it had a couple of standout funny moments, but otherwise I really didn't enjoy it at all. The fact that I couldn't stand
Stephenie in Palau, and that I knew (and didn't like) Rafe in real life certainly didn't help. I have always sort of had a personal grudge against
Guatemala.
Bobby Jon and Judd almost saved it for me though. |
|||
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
How does Borneo not hold up well? And why do you find S12 so boring?
|
|||
Apprentice Talker |
|||
|
1. All-Stars
2. Panama 3. Australia 4. Africa 5. Micronesia 6. Cook Islands 7. China 8. Borneo 9. Amazon 10. Marquesas 11. Vanuatu 12. Guatemala 13. Pearl Islands 14. Palau 15. Thailand 16. Fiji |
|||
SenseiKreese |
|||
|
Watch Borneo now. The first two or three episodes are almost unwatchable. They didn't really figure out what they were doing, production-wise, until
about the fourth episode.
And how do you explain why you found a season boring? With Exile Island I just did. I have seen it three times and I couldn't even tell you what happened in most of the episodes. I barely even remember the winner. In fact when you referred to it as "S12", I actually had to stop and think about which season that was. There's a reason the Funny 115 ends with Guatemala. It's because Guatemala and (in particular) Exile Island were when I sort of lost interest in the show for a while. The addition of a final three in Cook Islands didn't help either. I have never been a fan of the final three. Part of the reason I ranked Micronesia so high on my list is because we actually went back to a F2, and I was ecstatic. |
|||
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Well,different strokes for different folks.I like all the seasons, but in relative terms, Marquesas to me is awful(at least the post merge anyway). I thought
Panama had one of the best casts ever and the only fault I have with that season is the editing. If they had focused more on Casayas crazy antics
premerge/antagonism with Terry at the merge as opposed to it being a standard issue "underdog story" with Terry,then it would be seen as one of the
best seasons.
I respectfully disagree with you about Borneo. Al the psiodes are great.The only problem I have with Borneo(which is miniscule) is that they reused footage.They showed the same scene of Rudy throwing a knife in two subsequent episodes-why? |
|||