Yuku free message boards

As far as the edited fooling of Cirie:

"But it made complete sense for the editors to illustrate that Amanda was doomed because she was unable to get both Cirie and Erik's vote. If Cirie was shown as in on the plan, we'd have known Amanda was safe before TC."

Agreed, but they didn't need to show us Cirie saying she couldn't beat Amanda in front of the jury + They didn't need to have Cirie asking where Amanda was + They didn't need to have Cirie pointing the finger at Amanda during TC. The edited story was that Cirie wanted Amanda gone, didn't know she had the idol and was fooled by the result.

"I can see where you point out that Cirie didn't appear to be in the loop, I just didn't agree she was "fooled"

So, we are arguing over semantics. Call it what you like but the real sequence of events probably had Amanda holding the idol when she asked Cirie how she was voting. Amanda told her about having it or being able to get it only after Cirie admitted she would have wanted it to be PAC to the end. That implies a level of deception on Amanda's part. She got Cirie to commit to one side. Cirie had benefitted from being the swing vote when Malakal was divided at 9. Now Dabu is divided at 5 and Cirie has less elbow room.

"You have absolutely no idea when Cirie was made aware"

Absolutely no idea? Talk about disconnected with reality! Maybe you suspect ESP and that Cirie knew before Amanda went to Exile Island, maybe even before going to Micronesia!!

I do have an exact idea that, when Cirie was made aware of the idol, Natalie, Alexis, Erik and herself had already committed to vote out Amanda. That part about fearing the purple rock wasn't the talk of someone knowing Amanda was about to bounce the votes to Alexis. Duh!

I'm fairly certain that Amanda told Cirie about the idol immediately after Cirie told her "You know I wanted to go to the end with you and Parv". I even think Amanda had dug out the idol already despite the way the sequences were shown. Even then, it doesn't change my statement that the votes were all set before Cirie knew how it was going down. Cirie was out of the loop, tricked, surprised, fooled, call it whatever you want, it had never happened before, thus my ranking comment.

chapera rocks wrote:

---

PARVATI - 9 (One point off for sucking at the trivia. 0 points? Come on.)

CR: Didn't Parvati get the Skupin question right?