Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
Kitty Pryde1		#1261	[-]
Posts: 3785 (04/27/08 11:33 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	5. Exile Island (Tina, Melinda, Misty, Ruth Marie, Bobby, Dan, Nick, Austin, Sally, Bruce, Courtney, Shane, Cirie, Danielle, Aras) I know Exile Island gets a lot of love, and the fact is that New Casaya was one of the best tribes of all time. The problem is that the New La Mina tribe mainly made the season boring. If you look at the episodes, you'll see boring streaks from 2-4 and 6-9. Granted, once the Pagonging was basically over, the season went into legendary proportions, with Cirie showing just how much of a genius she is, Terry dominating the hell out of challenges, Bruce/Courtney/Shane doing crazy shit, and Danielle and Aras...yeah. That was another problem I had with EI. Going into the final 7, it was 5 good characters, 2 lame. Final 6: 4 good, 2 lame. Final 5: 3 good, 2 lame. Final 4: 2 good, 2 lame. Final 3: 1 good, 2 lame. Final 2: WHAT THE HECK HAPPENED TO ALL THE AWESOME PEOPLE?! Most disappointing final 2 ever. Had even ONE of the other 5 made the final 2, the season would've been legendary. Also, this season introduced Exile Island, which has been the bane of several seasons since, so I've gotta knock it down for that too.
Edinboro		#1262	[-]
Posts: 933 (04/27/08 11:42 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Kitty Pryde1 wrote: 10. Survivor: Cook Islands (Sekou, Billy, Cecilia, JP, Stephannie, Cao Boi, Cristina, Flica, Brad, Rebecca, Jenny, Nate, Candice, Jonathan, Parvati, Adam, Sundra, Becky, Ozzy, Yul) Seasons with twenty people will always suck, because far too often are players ignored amidst the many possible characters that could be showcased. This season also had the problem of the first two episodes being better than the entire rest of the season. Watching the few interesting players, like Sekou, Billy, Stephannie, Cao Boi, and Flica get taken out early was bad, but having nearly the entire endgame populated by boring, pretty, young people wasn't cool. I'll give Cook Islands credit for having a good underdog story that worked perfectly, and for casting Jonathan, the most interesting person in the entire game. I also liked watching Ozzy go on his immunity run. The season gets deducted points for having a bunch of twists around mid-game that ended up screwing EVERYONE but the Aitu 4, plus the fact that despite casting only 5 white people, they still made up half of the elite 8. Overall, Cook Islands just wound up being a pretty meh season. Wow. This is the fifth one i read and all you do is bash them. Do you like any season? Seriously. Love ya Kitty, but you ranked some of the greatest seasons so low..Exile Island 5!!! Please. Last Edited By: Edinboro 04/27/08 11:48 AM. Edited 1 times.
Edinboro		#1263	[-]
Posts: 934 (04/27/08 11:44 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	spnintendo wrote: After being in a similar position playing certain anonymous ORG (), I have a new respect for Kucha. hmm..I wonder what game that was. not sas though.
Kitty Pryde1		#1264	[-]
Posts: 3834 (04/28/08 11:40 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	4. Survivor: Vanuatu (Brook, Dolly, John P., Mia, Brady, Bubba, Lisa, John K., Rory, Sarge, Chad, Leann, Ami, Julie, Eliza, Scout, Twila, Chris) Vanuatu is like the reverse of the past two seasons. It had a really crappy beginning (probably what made it such a bad season in the eyes of the mainstream public), but it also had a great post-merge. As I mentioned before, everyone who made the merge (except Leann) is in my top 100 favorite Survivor players, so things really worked out well there. It had some great drama and perhaps the greatest underdog story of all time. Watching the women implode was hilarious, especially since it came at the hands of crazy Eliza. Chris is one of the most entertaining winners of all time, and it's so awesome how a guy like him (red-neckish) won a season that was so heavily tilted in the women's favor (Only two women who might actually consider flirting with the guys out of a group of nine, the opening ceremony designed to piss the women off). It was a great ending that couldn't have gone any better.
Bobby Jon goes apeshit		#1265	[-]
Posts: 1171 (04/28/08 11:42 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Edinboro wrote: Love ya Kitty, but you ranked some of the greatest seasons so low..Exile Island 5!!! Please. Yes. Who could resist such CLASSIC seasons like Palau, Cook Islands etc
A Dying Clown		#1266	[-]
Posts: 5936 (04/28/08 11:44 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Guatemala being a shock entry into the Final 3 appreciation.
spnintendo		#1267	[-]
Posts: 2588 (04/28/08 12:17 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	EI was only great in comparison to the S9-S11 mactor/bloatedness. Against the pre-ASS seasons, I dunno man. And Vanuatu?? :pukey :pukey
Zesty66		#1268	[-]
Posts: 361 (04/28/08 3:04 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I loved Vanuatu. I was pleasantly surprised watching it for the first time after finding out it was viewed as one of the worst seasons here.
Quiddity		#1269	[-]
Posts: 2328 (04/28/08 3:06 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	A Dying Clown wrote: Guatemala being a shock entry into the Final 3 appreciation. X. I loved Guatemala, and am quite happy that it'll be finishing so high :P
SurvivorFanGP		#1270	[-]
Posts: 7466 (04/28/08 3:50 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Quiddity wrote: A Dying Clown wrote: Guatemala being a shock entry into the Final 3 appreciation. X. I loved Guatemala, and am quite happy that it'll be finishing so high :P wonders if you would still love Guatemala if the fabulous StepheBitch deservingly beat Danni
AidanAcello		#1271	[-]
Posts: 1294 (04/28/08 6:56 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Major Vanuatu LOVE
Quiddity		#1272	[-]
Posts: 2344 (04/28/08 7:17 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	SurvivorFanGP wrote: Quiddity wrote: A Dying Clown wrote: Guatemala being a shock entry into the Final 3 appreciation. X. I loved Guatemala, and am quite happy that it'll be finishing so high :P wonders if you would still love Guatemala if the fabulous StepheBitch deservingly beat Danni Well of course not. The fall of Queen Stephenie post-merge was certainly a big factor in my enjoyment of the season, making up at least somewhat for the fact that my fave, who was brutally backstabbed by the Queen herself didn't win.
Mister Plum		#1273	[-]
Posts: 1707 (04/28/08 8:25 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I'm not a fan of Vanuatu but it truly deserves a high ranking but Guatemala?? Seriously?
Bobby Jon eats apeshit		#1274	[-]
Posts: 4 (04/29/08 5:53 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Who could resist such CLASSIC seasons like Palau, Cook Islands etc
AMBERFREAK		#1275	[-]
Posts: 1283 (04/29/08 9:13 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Vanuatu was great. At the time, I couldn't stand that Chris won, but his victory still made for a good story.
Kitty Pryde1		#1276	[-]
Posts: 3851 (04/29/08 11:03 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	3. Survivor: Marquesas (Peter, Patricia, Hunter, Sarah, Gabriel, Gina, Rob, John, Zoe, Tammy, Robert, Sean, Paschal, Kathy, Neleh, Vecepia) Marquesas was the first season where things were really up in the air in terms of who would be going home. For the first three seasons, there was some backstabbing, but for the most part, it was a pretty clean game. You stick with one alliance and don't betray until the other team is gone entirely. Marquesas flipped that on its head completely. Starting with the elimination of arguably the strongest guy on the show in episode THREE, Marquesas became a VERY interesting season. There was a tribe swap which put three of the biggest schemers on the Rotu love tribe. And those schemers did their part in helping take out the most likable cast member, who turned his own tribe against him for not being cutthroat enough. The merge ended up resulting in the first ever reversal of power as the Rotu 4 were taken down by the underdogs. The final two episodes were crazy and action-packed, and resulted in the third-best winner of all time. If it weren't for the overall bitterness and spitefulness of the jury, Marquesas could've been in the top two for me.
spnintendo		#1277	[-]
Posts: 2610 (04/29/08 11:06 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Cool fact: Marquesas was the first season I watched from start to finish on TV. For that, it'll always hold a special place in my heart. <3
Us Kids Know		#1278	[-]
Posts: 5447 (04/29/08 11:24 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Vecepia is definitely one of the 15 best winners (16 in the next few weeks <3). I love Marquesas, but I never really got the excitement over the downfall of the Rotu four. I mean, I was excited because I hate them (except Tammy <3), but it wasn't all that different from the past pagongings. OMG, this time the pagongers are from two different tribes!!1!1! Once John left, you knew what you were in for the next 3 weeks, and I didn't find John's boot shocking in the first place. But like I said, it's probably a top 4 or 5 season for me.
Edinboro		#1279	[-]
Posts: 981 (04/29/08 2:19 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Marquesas ranks as my 12 th fav. season..
Edinboro		#1280	[-]
Posts: 982 (04/29/08 2:20 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Yul looks gay on the cover of cook islands

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

Quick Reply