Rank the 2nd Placers

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (Apprentice Talker) — Tue, 13 May 2008 06:01:05 GMT

1. Rob Mariano
2. Colby Donaldson
3. Amanda Kimmel
4. Ozzy Lusth
5. Neleh Dennis
6. Kim Johnson
7. Kelly Wiglesworth
8. Courtney Yates
9. Clay Jordan
10. Matthew von Ertfelda
11. Stephenie LaGrossa
12. Danielle DiLorenzo
13. Katie Gallagher
14. Twila Tanner
15. Lillian Morris
16. Dre Herd
17. Cassandra Franklin

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (A Dying Clown) — Tue, 13 May 2008 05:04:17 GMT

1. Courtney <3
2. Matt
3. Lill
4. Clay
5. Dreamz
6. Rob
7. Kim
8. Danielle
9. Katie
10. Steph
11. Colby
12. Kelly
13. Neleh
14. Twila
15. Ozztard
16. Amanda
17. Cassandra

Wow,...

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (Cassidy666) — Tue, 13 May 2008 03:26:19 GMT

unduli clone wrote:

01. Courtney
02. Katie
...
16. Amanda

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (SurvivorNinja) — Tue, 13 May 2008 01:11:36 GMT

I'm going to kill 20 birds with one stone....(not based soley on gameplay)

FIRST PLACE
1. Danni
2. Hatch
3. Sandra
4. Parvati
5. Vee
6. Todd
7. Chris
8. Heidik
9. Amber
10. Jenna
11. Tom
12. Tina
13. Yul
14. Aras
15. Ethan
16. Earl

SECOND PLACE
1. Courtney
2. Matthew
3. Amanda
4. Kelly
5. Colby
6. Lillian...

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (Katy Carney) — Tue, 13 May 2008 01:10:43 GMT

I was just doing runners-up and was confused since Dreamz and Cassandra were both in Fiji, but then I remembered that they both got zero votes.

I edited.

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (chad6) — Tue, 13 May 2008 00:27:03 GMT

Why are some poeple ranking Amanda twice and Becky. Amanda came in 3rd in China, not 2nd. And Becky came in 3rd in the Cooks.

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (Katy Carney) — Mon, 12 May 2008 23:45:33 GMT

1. Rob
2. Stephenie
3. Colby
4. Courtney
5. Twila
6. Ozzy
7. Danielle
8. Kelly
9. Katie
10. Cassandra
11. Dreamz
12. Neleh
13. Amanda
14. Lill
15. Matt
16. Clay

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (RavuRules) — Mon, 12 May 2008 21:10:18 GMT

Ozzy isn't just limited to physical domination, especially not in Micronesia. He's demonstrated a certain level of strategic and social ability too, enough where if he ever makes the finals, he'd likely win. Barring going up against a triple threat finalist like Yul, many individuals have stated that he'd win the game. So unless 1 of the individuals he's chosen to trust like Parvati backstab him and prevent him from reaching the finals, his chances of winning and...

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (GelEGuy2) — Mon, 12 May 2008 21:03:35 GMT

Ozzy's gotta' be one of the most polarizing Survivor players ever. I mean, I know that Rupert is polarizing, but that's a case of "regular" fans loving him, and Sucksters despising him. Ozzy, though, seems to divide many Sucksters.

Obviously, I fall in the Ozzy-was-terrible camp. No one has won this game with a strategy consisting of just physical domination. Sure, Brian and Tom dominated their seasons physically, but they also played very political games...

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (ShadowBlade11) — Mon, 12 May 2008 20:36:31 GMT

1. Ozzy (Say what you want, but he did an excellent job)
2. Boston Rob (He ran the show, for god sakes!)
3. Twila
4. Colby
5. Clay
6. Stephenie
7. Amanda (China)
8. Neleh
9. Dreamz (Without him there would be no Edgardo surprise oust!)
10. Kelly
11. Lillian
12. Katie
13. Amanda (Micronesia)
14. Matt
15. Danielle
16. Becky
17. Courtney
18. Cassandra (Has she done anything major other than tag along?)

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (GelEGuy2) — Mon, 12 May 2008 20:18:28 GMT

17--Dreamz
16--Matt
15--Cassandra
14--Ozzy
13--Neleh
12--Kim J.
11--Kelly
10--Katie
9--Danielle
8--Courtney
7--Clay
6--Stephenie
5--Amanda
4--Lillian
3--Colby
2--Rob
1--Twila

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (unduli clone) — Mon, 12 May 2008 19:36:24 GMT

01. Courtney
02. Katie
...
16. Amanda

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (TheLurkerSpeaks) — Mon, 12 May 2008 16:14:32 GMT

TheLurkerSpeaks wrote: (update in italics)
I think it is harder to rank the runners up than the winners. The winners actually all achieved their goal so we can evaluate how they got there. With the losers, there's a lot more question of whether they could have won if only ...

Still, the criteria should be the same. Split the game between positioning skill and...

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (JaMalle) — Sat, 26 Jan 2008 16:34:58 GMT

I feel the need to update my rankings after a few seasons have passed. New additions- Dreamz (it was between him and Earl; no one was going to give the money to Cassandra), Courtney, and Ozzy.

JaMalle's Old rankings:

1. Rob
2. Twila
3. Katie
4. Kelly
5. Clay
6. Danielle
7. Lil
8. Neleh
9. Mama Kim
10. Colby
11. Matt
12. Steph

1. Rob - Remains at...

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (panurge46) — Sat, 26 Jan 2008 13:23:17 GMT

Juggler 8o8 wrote:
I never understood why anyone would consider her a great player

No other winner managed to turn a situation where they were #5 in an failing alliance and turn it around with 1 boot (Mitchell's) to become the leader of that alliance, making it stronger in the process.

Silas did something similar in Samburu by voting out Carl but his method finished the destruction of the...

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (Juggler 8o8) — Fri, 25 Jan 2008 21:47:01 GMT

Yea Tina is overrated. I never understood why anyone would consider her a great player

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (RavuRules) — Fri, 25 Jan 2008 13:07:29 GMT

Yes, I am well aware. That was my point to Ravu, that Keith was edited that way.

Oh sorry. I had no idea you were addressing me. I thought you were talking about someone else. Trust me, I'm aware editing plays a huge role in things. Without evidence or proof though, distinguishing just how much makes things controversial, hence all the circular discussions, speculations, and debates between all of us

Why do you...

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (amcoolio1) — Fri, 25 Jan 2008 12:27:50 GMT

Yes, I am well aware. That was my point to Ravu, that Keith was edited that way.

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (Robert Qld) — Thu, 24 Jan 2008 02:01:47 GMT

amcoolio1 wrote:
Why do you think everyone disliked Keith? He wasn't portrayed on the show as someone who is abrasive. In fact, viewers kinda liked Keith. But why didn't any of the castaways?

It is called editing. You'll be shocked at what editors have been known to do!

Actually to be fair, the best example is Kim Johnson. She was edited to be fairly likeable to the viewing public...

Re: Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (amcoolio1) — Wed, 23 Jan 2008 12:29:42 GMT

Why do you think everyone disliked Keith? He wasn't portrayed on the show as someone who is abrasive. In fact, viewers kinda liked Keith. But why didn't any of the castaways?

Just because the season is edited one way doesn't mean it proves it to be right. To say Keith had as much power in the KTC alliance as Tina (and another thing, why would you take your own word, when you say you haven't seen/thought about Australia in a long time, over Colby?) is crazy. Colby...

Rank the 2nd Placers

feeds@yuku.com (fanofcoils) — Fri, 19 May 2006 20:18:41 GMT

I have only seen about half of the seasons (and read a little bit about the other seasons). I will try my best.

(1 is best, 12 is worst)

1. Lil (Decided to vote out Rupert. Blindsided Jon at the end with her immunity victory at F3. Obviously she wasn't that great because she didn't win but I think she was the best 2nd placer).

2. Clay (What could he have done differently? Not sure. I missed the season though.)

3. Twila (I think she did pretty...