OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (Olmec Donald) — Thu, 26 Nov 2009 08:53:22 GMT

JerseyJerk wrote:
That merge/mutiny idea would be cool but it would be so lackluster if not would DID mutiny.

Does anyone want to mutiny?
No?
Ok well now your merged

They don't have to show the mutiny offer in the episode if they don't want to.

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (JerseyJerk) — Thu, 26 Nov 2009 01:04:09 GMT

That merge/mutiny idea would be cool but it would be so lackluster if not would DID mutiny.

Does anyone want to mutiny?
No?
Ok well now your merged

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (Remote33) — Wed, 25 Nov 2009 23:45:21 GMT

I keep saying this but it would be REALLY interesting to see 8 dating/married couples competing, one person on each tribe. It's always interesting on The Biggest Loser when couples get put on separate teams.

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (qwerty) — Wed, 25 Nov 2009 23:08:02 GMT

LOL @ the mutiny and merge idea. that would be crazy

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (quicksilver82) — Tue, 24 Nov 2009 22:28:29 GMT

I think a neat twist would be when there are 12 people left. Ask if anyone wants to Mutiny. If anyone does they will then join the other tribe. Then Jeff tells them they are now merged into one tribe. That would certainly create a lot of chaos at the merge. LOL

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (Cyberball2072) — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 14:44:09 GMT

Maybe Johnny Bannas and Coral Jean Smith from the RealWorld/RoadRules challenges.

Sanjaya is a great choice.

Omarosa, definite.

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (qwerty) — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 02:17:19 GMT

Cyberball2072 wrote:
SURVIVOR- GAME MASTERS edition.....

This season is reserved to players that are truely masters of the game, win or lose. Those players that showed manipulation and such on such a level that they are unquestioned masters of their crafts are in this season. People like Richard hatch, Rob Cesterino, Rob Mariano, etc, etc.

And this would also be open to other reality show...

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (Maximus20) — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 16:38:43 GMT

I didnt read everything in this thread, so apologizes if this is brought up,

But iv always thought it would be intresting.

Just ONE season.

To let EVERY castaway vote on the winner. Make the jury start from the first castaway voted out untill the f3/f2

It might be a well received twist, or not.

But I always thought it would be a cool idea. because that way castaways would have to be careful about who they pissed off from day 1.

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (Kubin) — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 16:13:21 GMT

another reboot for the Hidden Immunity challenge. if you have the idol and you got voted off, Instead of having the 2nd person with the most votes voted off, You will get to challenge any castaway on a 1 on 1 challenge and the loser of that challenge will go home.

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (JerseyJerk) — Sun, 15 Nov 2009 02:03:28 GMT

Well I am being realistic AND sensible in this in that I'm not going to say "Make its gays vs straights" or "3 HII"S!":

Seeing as the HII has become all but incredibly easy to find in the past few seasons, and in this seasons case Russell has found it TWICE without clues, there should be a rule that you can use the HII once, and only once and ONLY by the person who has it in their *possession.

Possession is obtained by the person who finds the...

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (Kubin) — Sun, 15 Nov 2009 00:11:53 GMT

Change of rules with the Hidden American idol:

If you found the idol during premerge, You get a guaranteed merge spot instead. You found it at the merge you get a 3 week immunity. That will shake things up.

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (Kubin) — Sat, 14 Nov 2009 01:29:27 GMT

TheEasyOne wrote:
The greatest "twist" of all would be NO CONTESTANTS from CA at least for 1 season. How amazing would that be.

This......

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (TheEasyOne) — Fri, 13 Nov 2009 18:08:32 GMT

The greatest "twist" of all would be NO CONTESTANTS from CA at least for 1 season. How amazing would that be.

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (saiwong) — Thu, 12 Nov 2009 10:35:58 GMT

Cyberball2072 wrote:
SURVIVOR- GAME MASTERS edition.....

This season is reserved to players that are truely masters of the game, win or lose. Those players that showed manipulation and such on such a level that they are unquestioned masters of their crafts are in this season. People like Richard hatch, Rob Cesterino, Rob Mariano, etc, etc.

And this would also be open to other reality show...

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (7o62x39) — Wed, 11 Nov 2009 15:53:30 GMT

Here are several thoughts of mine on what I believe to be widely held or perhaps even consensus opinion about the fan's thoughts on Survivor game design

1) Many fans want a return to old school Survivor - 16 castaways, 2 tribes, mostly fan/applicants, no pre-merge swap, no Exile or HII, merge at 10, Jury of 9, F2. The concern over doing so is that it invites predictable and unoriginal play which would likely follow conventional wisdom - kill the old and weak early and then...

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (Olmec Donald) — Mon, 09 Nov 2009 07:44:12 GMT

Sounds great, 7o. You should also check out the Future Challenge Ideas thread, currently sitting on page 2.

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (7o62x39) — Sun, 08 Nov 2009 09:05:33 GMT

I'm putting together a game design plan for S21 based on the best ideas I've read going back to Old SS, Acme Brain Trust, Elipsiiis, Pygmy, SF, new Sucks and other boards. I'm not going to go crazy and reinvent the show. The biggest change is to go with the 3 x 6 tribes initially as the primary anti-Pagonging system allowing us to avoid doing one of those horrid pre-merge random tribal swaps.

I'm really interested in your thoughts on RC, IC and RC/IC challenge...

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (ActingDude17) — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 21:01:08 GMT

America as an additional jury vote. Not even a long-time thing, per se, maybe just try it one season.

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (7o62x39) — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 11:27:33 GMT

(I posted a version of this in the Three Tribes thread, but it discusses more than three tribes and I probably should have posted here). Here are several twists I've been advocating since the early years.

THREE TRIBES E1-E4/5 - 18 INITIAL SURVIVORS
The purpose of 3 tribes is to stress tribes and reduce the likelihood of Pagonging (the systematic elimination of the minority at the merge) without having to resort to a random pre-merge swap which creates too...

Re: OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (twisted1982) — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 04:57:48 GMT

I think permanent kidnapping of a tribe member could be an interesting twist.

OFFICIAL Idea's and Twists for Survivor

feeds@yuku.com (Cyberball2072) — Sun, 21 Sep 2008 09:14:36 GMT

Come here, come all, to post all your now and future idea's and twists of things that are REASONABLE and that could make Survivor better. My main idea, is we already have the hidden immunity (which I love). But I think that perhaps, when it gets to Individual Immunity, to have MULTIPLE Immunity Necklaces, would really turn the game around. For example, the first Individual Immunity challenge is done and Player A has won it. And now, Jeff Probst brings out a board that has 6 or 7...