James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (The Annoying Hater) — Fri, 09 May 2008 10:51:23 GMT

Uh, COLBY has always been, and still is the dumbest survivor ever BY FAR, for bringing Tina to the finals and basically handing her a million dollars.

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (XXWildcat) — Fri, 09 May 2008 09:21:39 GMT

The island gatekeeper wrote:
CirieOwl > Greedy James > Lividmanda

Cirie has never been voted out of Survivor.

Neither has Lividmanda, and she's been on longer than anyone else.

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (kishuu) — Fri, 09 May 2008 09:19:51 GMT

The thing was, the other people that gave up individual immunity didn't get voted out while he did, especially knowing that the women's alliance reigned supreme.

Jenna didn't get voted out. Burton already had immunity. You have to agree Erik is dumb even though he's such a super fan. James trusted his alliance too much tbh, if he didn't have the two idols, the target would've been lifted off his back except for the physical factor.

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (CatNamedRudy) — Fri, 09 May 2008 07:19:30 GMT

No way that James is still the dumbest. James is still dumb but I actually think both Erik and Jason overtook him.

Jason because he had JUST SEEN Ozzy blindsided the week before and he knew about the James in China thing and Erik because well...COME ON! He KNEW every one of those women was pissed at him. He sat there and listened to them all talk about how he had lied to all of them. He saw what they did to Ozzy and Jason and he saw what Amanda did to Alexis the week before....

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (m0t0 maj1) — Fri, 09 May 2008 07:02:17 GMT

The greatest heel of all time wrote:
James had TWO IIs, his greedy ways cost him the game. James never tried to use those idols to help further him in the game.

Greedy James thought he could coast to the final 5 or 6, that everyone would just roll out the red carpet for him.

Erik knew he had to win immunity in the F4, Erik took a risk instead of trying his hand at an F4 endurance challenge...

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (sir debb eaton hogg) — Fri, 09 May 2008 06:58:19 GMT

While it's getting closer, James still reigns supreme

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (Blondzilla5150) — Fri, 09 May 2008 06:44:59 GMT

iamsurvivorgod wrote:

And for that, Erik will not be considered the dumbest player move
You must be on crack. There is no other way you could have posted something this stupid. Either that, or you're canadian.

I'll bet money they are someone who is smokin' crack, up in canada.

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (Blondzilla5150) — Fri, 09 May 2008 06:44:59 GMT

iamsurvivorgod wrote:

And for that, Erik will not be considered the dumbest player move
You must be on crack. There is no other way you could have posted something this stupid. Either that, or you're canadian.

I'll bet money they are someone who is smokin' crack, up in canada.

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (iamsurvivorgod) — Fri, 09 May 2008 06:41:45 GMT

And for that, Erik will not be considered the dumbest player move

You must be on crack. There is no other way you could have posted something this stupid. Either that, or you're canadian.

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (Loony Moonie) — Fri, 09 May 2008 06:20:14 GMT

Don't think so. James was blindsided after all. He trusted his alliance and had no reason to predict his boot coming. Erik wasn't allied with the 4 women and knew that his boot was coming at the time Immunity was not with him - or he should know, because it was obvious. He didn't lose. He gave them his head. It was stupid.

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (The island gatekeeper) — Fri, 09 May 2008 06:11:42 GMT

CirieOwl > Greedy James > Lividmanda

Cirie has never been voted out of Survivor.

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (Lake Like The Ocean) — Fri, 09 May 2008 06:04:02 GMT

Erik's move was editted to look a lot dumber than it was. Cirie and Natalie gave a convincing argument, and since Erik had flip-flopped so much earlier... it's reasonable to think Cirie might need a little assurance that Erik's word was true before damaging her alliance with Parvati and Amanda.. They outwitted him, true. It was a dumb move, but not as dumb as James.

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (Lex Van den strategy) — Fri, 09 May 2008 06:01:51 GMT

GREEDY JAMES???

Re: James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (thailand caffeine) — Fri, 09 May 2008 06:00:57 GMT

omg Greedy James(tm)

James is still the dumbest Survivor ever

feeds@yuku.com (The greatest heel of all time) — Fri, 09 May 2008 05:58:17 GMT

James had TWO IIs, his greedy ways cost him the game. James never tried to use those idols to help further him in the game.

Greedy James thought he could coast to the final 5 or 6, that everyone would just roll out the red carpet for him.

Erik knew he had to win immunity in the F4, Erik took a risk instead of trying his hand at an F4 endurance challenge against bottom heavy balancing Parvati. Erik would have been taken into the F3 if Parvati was voted out, because no...