If exile island returns

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (GrenadeJumper85) — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 16:35:44 GMT

could very well be a Amanda/Courtney

Then Courtney would have probably won, still a good winner either way with Courtney or Todd.

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (Mister Plum) — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 02:38:22 GMT

Syoma wrote:

Mister Plum wrote:

survivorisdabest wrote:
Horrible CI twists:
-message in a bottle
-Race twist
-final 3

Horrible Fiji twists:
-F10 split into 2 tribes
-Rich vs Poor...

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (Syoma) — Tue, 29 Apr 2008 02:00:43 GMT

Mister Plum wrote:

survivorisdabest wrote:
Horrible CI twists:
-message in a bottle
-Race twist
-final 3

Horrible Fiji twists:
-F10 split into 2 tribes
-Rich vs Poor
-final 3

CI edges out Fiji in horribleness since it was the first to...

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (the one and only squigee) — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 20:16:10 GMT

I hate how everyone STILL rips on the final three! Without it Cook Islands would have been an Ozzy/Becky affair (yeh he lucked out with the idol but at least Yul had a strategy while the only reason for an Ozzy win was....er....he was quite good at challenges....), Fiji would have been a DREAMZ/CASSANDRA end (seriously....seriously!!!) and yeh China could very well be a Amanda/Courtney end, and yes i know everyone loves Courtney but i think it's fair to say that Todd was the most...

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (sweEt Mauritius) — Mon, 28 Apr 2008 13:02:37 GMT

CSCin3D wrote:
What was so great about China in the first place? Everyone here just orgasmed at the beginning of the season when there were 16 castaways and no exile island. You all FORCED yourselves to like it. Take a look back and you'll find it was boring. Pre-merge what was there as far as entertainment value... Dave's lame-ass bickering with Ashley and Sherea? Zhan-Hu throwing the challenge to get rid of Aaron? Post...

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (Kitty Pryde1) — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 22:31:18 GMT

If only Todd was 200 pounds heavier, female, and blonde, CSC would LOVE China.

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (XtremeInnovator420) — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 22:24:39 GMT

Maybe in your opinion that's what he was, but I actually was rooting for the little guy from the get go.

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (CSCin3D) — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 21:46:42 GMT

A ferret-like weaselly little bitch winner does not a great season make.

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (Kirblar) — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 21:40:08 GMT

China was great because of 13/16 castmembers made great TV and we finally got a fan-geek winner. (Amanda, Denise and Erik being the duds.)

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (CSCin3D) — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 21:07:16 GMT

What was so great about China in the first place? Everyone here just orgasmed at the beginning of the season when there were 16 castaways and no exile island. You all FORCED yourselves to like it. Take a look back and you'll find it was boring. Pre-merge what was there as far as entertainment value... Dave's lame-ass bickering with Ashley and Sherea? Zhan-Hu throwing the challenge to get rid of Aaron? Post merge wasn't much better. Todd/Amanda/Courtney pagonged everyone until...

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (sweEt Mauritius) — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 20:54:27 GMT

CSCin3D wrote:
Micronesia was WAY better than China so far

How? It must just be personal taste but there's no way Micronesia is better than China for me so far. Who knows, maybe there will be an amazing rest of the season enough to make it overtake China, but I doubt it.

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (XtremeInnovator420) — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 16:32:19 GMT

I....would agree that Exile Island and more than 16 people doesn't instantly ruin a season.

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (CSCin3D) — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 16:17:45 GMT

Micronesia was WAY better than China so far, even with exile island and twenty castaways. That stuff doesn't automatically ruin a season.

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (sweEt Mauritius) — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 13:22:35 GMT

Kirblar wrote:
Fiji was the season that finally made them take a step back and take a hard look at what wasn't working with the show anymore.

China/Micronesia have been far, far better than any other post-ASS seasons, and I'm not sure that would have happened without that disaster shocking some sense into them.

I beg to differ! Grouping China and Micronesia...

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (tullfan2) — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 08:14:29 GMT

Quiddity wrote:

cardswin5 wrote:
I know Fiji sucked but the final 3 saved it. Otherwise Dreamz would have won immunity and voted out Earl for being a threat at the end.

Then who would have won? Cassandra? Dreamz? Survivor would have been like canceled out of horribleness.

The point of the F3 was to eliminate the blowout...

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (Mister Plum) — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 00:19:35 GMT

survivorisdabest wrote:
Horrible CI twists:
-message in a bottle
-Race twist
-final 3

Horrible Fiji twists:
-F10 split into 2 tribes
-Rich vs Poor
-final 3

CI edges out Fiji in horribleness since it was the first to have the final 3.

I love the race twist.

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (Quiddity) — Sun, 27 Apr 2008 00:01:12 GMT

cardswin5 wrote:
I know Fiji sucked but the final 3 saved it. Otherwise Dreamz would have won immunity and voted out Earl for being a threat at the end.

Then who would have won? Cassandra? Dreamz? Survivor would have been like canceled out of horribleness.

The point of the F3 was to eliminate the blowout final votes by not having the F3 immunity challenge winner bring a goat to the end. It was also...

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (cardswin5) — Sat, 26 Apr 2008 23:18:56 GMT

I know Fiji sucked but the final 3 saved it. Otherwise Dreamz would have won immunity and voted out Earl for being a threat at the end.

Then who would have won? Cassandra? Dreamz? Survivor would have been like canceled out of horribleness.

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (XtremeInnovator420) — Sat, 26 Apr 2008 22:24:00 GMT

I'd actually say that having the final 3 in Cook Islands wasn't that bad at all as it was a big shock to the players. With Fiji it wasn't that great at all, especially since Earl had that massive blowout.

Re: If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (Kirblar) — Sat, 26 Apr 2008 21:58:57 GMT

Fiji was the season that finally made them take a step back and take a hard look at what wasn't working with the show anymore.

China/Micronesia have been far, far better than any other post-ASS seasons, and I'm not sure that would have happened without that disaster shocking some sense into them.

If exile island returns

feeds@yuku.com (TheEasyOne) — Sat, 26 Apr 2008 18:19:46 GMT

(Not encouraging it to return, and I wouldn't mind if HII & exile island dissappeared forever) but more than 1 exile island might be interesting. Have the exilee(s) get a choice on which island they want to go to (Island 1 or Island 2).

For the HII there could be one idol on both islands or one idol on one island, nothing on the other.

Also instead of basically having the search for HII be a physical scavenger hunt which guarentees that a man finds it, they...