Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (Kitty Pryde1) — Thu, 24 Sep 2009 15:10:27 GMT

I'm gonna wait until the end of the season to rank characters this time, that way I can do them in order and their positions won't be changing every time someone new is added to the list.

ETA: Oh wait...this is my old list. I've gotta go find my revised list.

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (SleepTight) — Tue, 22 Sep 2009 16:22:42 GMT

Just read this whole thing in one hour. Gotta say, epic list. Mine would be different, but it was still fun to read.

I would like to do one of these one day but the top 10 would pretty much be filled with asians.

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (Mister Plum) — Thu, 21 May 2009 01:00:25 GMT

He's a borewhore but nope.

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (Joaqenix) — Wed, 20 May 2009 08:19:19 GMT

Katy Carney wrote:
I'm not mad at him, but I also don't give him credit he doesn't deserve. He didn't do anything wrong by agreeing with everyone who was determined to drag his stumpy ass to the end, it wasn't great gameplay. He's not even an amazing physical competitor. There's really not much to say about him. It's like...he showed up and was really Southern, and people were like "awwww can...

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (beatles20147) — Tue, 19 May 2009 21:21:35 GMT

JT's "win" is a special case. There has never been a season where people were ACTIVELY TRYING to make someone else win.

Seriously, so many people this season were trying to get JT and Stephen to the end. In a few cases, it was based on strategic mistakes, but a lot of it was intentional. The only other person who made the merge who seemed to want to win was Tyson (and to a lesser extent, Erinn, but she still put herself in a F3 with two...

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (Dr Will Hatch two point oh) — Tue, 19 May 2009 20:37:05 GMT

A Dying Clown wrote:

I literally couldn't tell you one interesting thing about Danni or that Danni did.
She was plucky heroine who defeated the foul dragon Steph, even after all her allies had been slain <3

I think she's one of the better winners both strategically and likeability-wise, but her luck with the Final 6 immunity was definitely crucial - if she'd survived...

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (solesurvivor01) — Tue, 19 May 2009 19:51:33 GMT

Katy Carney wrote:
I'm not mad at him, but I also don't give him credit he doesn't deserve. He didn't do anything wrong by agreeing with everyone who was determined to drag his stumpy ass to the end, it wasn't great gameplay. He's not even an amazing physical competitor. There's really not much to say about him. It's like...he showed up and was really Southern, and people were like "awwww can...

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (chapera rocks) — Tue, 19 May 2009 19:47:21 GMT

Mikester wrote:
Not to mention the fact that JT gained a TON from the fact that Stephen sucked so hardcore at the FTC. Erinn's most recent interview said something about how if Stephen would have just taken credit for his game, he would have her hers and a "few others'" votes in the end.

It's not JT's fault that everyone else sucked, but it's amazing how much these people wanted him to...

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (Katy Carney) — Tue, 19 May 2009 19:45:35 GMT

I'm not mad at him, but I also don't give him credit he doesn't deserve. He didn't do anything wrong by agreeing with everyone who was determined to drag his stumpy ass to the end, it wasn't great gameplay. He's not even an amazing physical competitor. There's really not much to say about him. It's like...he showed up and was really Southern, and people were like "awwww can we give the money to him?" and that was it.

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (booga chicken george booga) — Tue, 19 May 2009 19:44:42 GMT

quack quack

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (Mikester) — Tue, 19 May 2009 19:42:14 GMT

Not to mention the fact that JT gained a TON from the fact that Stephen sucked so hardcore at the FTC. Erinn's most recent interview said something about how if Stephen would have just taken credit for his game, he would have her hers and a "few others'" votes in the end.

It's not JT's fault that everyone else sucked, but it's amazing how much these people wanted him to win solely for being the "warrior"

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (oh ehm gee) — Tue, 19 May 2009 19:35:47 GMT

Katy Carney wrote:
It's not about deserving. JT gets the money either way. But the entire season consisted of people going up to him and telling him how awesome he was and how they wanted to help get him to the end, and he agreed. That's not impressive to me. He's not even that good at being an alpha male. He wasn't that good at the challenges and in fact he cost his team some early challenges, so w/e....

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (JackSparrowBauer) — Tue, 19 May 2009 18:50:07 GMT

in fact he cost his team some early challenges

He was the reason SydneyG.oddess got out and didn't pwn the entire season. wtfg, JT.

seriously, though, he retardly booted Spencer for not performing well in ONE challenge, then he goes and loses the next 2.

JT sucks.

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (Katy Carney) — Tue, 19 May 2009 18:28:29 GMT

It's not about deserving. JT gets the money either way. But the entire season consisted of people going up to him and telling him how awesome he was and how they wanted to help get him to the end, and he agreed. That's not impressive to me. He's not even that good at being an alpha male. He wasn't that good at the challenges and in fact he cost his team some early challenges, so w/e. There's just nothing that special about him aside from how country he seems and that is...

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (JackSparrowBauer) — Tue, 19 May 2009 18:19:33 GMT

When someone wins without struggling, people will say that he/she won because her competitors are stupid. Of course not. It's a lame excuse to say that that winner is not really that deserving or whatever.

Some people who had "easy" wins is because of good gameplay on their part, but for people like JT and Bob, it really was because other people were stupid. Everyone in Tocantins wanted JT to win as soon as they merged. Add in the fact that...

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (Mister Plum) — Tue, 19 May 2009 18:07:28 GMT

When someone wins without struggling, people will say that he/she won because her competitors are stupid. Of course not. It's a lame excuse to say that that winner is not really that deserving or whatever.

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (oh ehm gee) — Tue, 19 May 2009 18:02:33 GMT

Us Kids Know wrote:
Your season writeup = spot on, though I honestly might place the season at the very bottom.

Ew @ JT #1, I would only put him above Yul and maybe a few others (Vee/Danni/Aras), blech. But you know me.

Surely by Vee/Danni/Aras you meant Bob/Amber/Aras, right?

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (Us Kids Know) — Tue, 19 May 2009 17:53:41 GMT

Your season writeup = spot on, though I honestly might place the season at the very bottom.

Ew @ JT #1, I would only put him above Yul and maybe a few others (Vee/Danni/Aras), blech. But you know me.

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (Katy Carney) — Tue, 19 May 2009 17:29:30 GMT

JT was handed victory and he never really played the game at all. He's not even that big of an immunity threat. He's an average guy with a southern accent and the latter is why he won.

Re: Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (RunawayJuror) — Tue, 19 May 2009 16:51:29 GMT

CSCin3D wrote:
JT's "win" is a special case. There has never been a season where people were ACTIVELY TRYING to make someone else win. Call the Thailand or Borneo casts stupid, but they all wanted to win and were playing for themselves. The Tocantins cast was loaded up with millionaires and people who just wanted to look good for the cameras, so they didn't care about winning. JT probably went around telling...

Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

feeds@yuku.com (Kitty Pryde1) — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 12:39:01 GMT

Given how bored I've been lately, I decided to rank the Survivors and make a topic about it. Then I got to thinking, and I ranked the 60 tribes as well. Soon enough, I'd ranked the Survivors, the tribes, the seasons, the MERGED tribes, the winners, and I've even been thinking of ranking the episodes when I get the chance. Anyway, I don't really feel that there need to be a big intro. I will keep track of my lists so you guys don't have to search through all the pages of...